A preliminary implementation of metabolic-based pH control to reduce CO2 usage in outdoor flat-panel photobioreactor cultivation of Nannochloropsis oceanica microalgae

Jun Wang, Theresa Rosov, Pierre Wensel, John McGowen, Wayne R. Curtis

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

3 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

A crucial challenge associated with high-density, commercial-scale, outdoor microalgal cultivation is maintaining pH stability without excessive use of CO2 buffering. This includes a media-dependent, intracellular metabolic proton imbalance leading to the alkalization or acidification of growth media that results when algae consume, respectively, nitrate or ammonium ions. Feeding these two nitrogen sources can theoretically achieve balanced proton metabolism as well as pH control that is economically more favorable as compared to CO2 buffering or acid/base addition. To accomplish this, a fed-batch nutrient feeding strategy must be adopted as a component of a model-based pH control system, particularly in the case of ammonium preference. This work represents a preliminary study of the challenges of implementing a nitrogen metabolism based open-loop pH control strategy in the challenging environment of an outdoor photobioreactor at the DOE-ATP3 testbed facility in Mesa, Arizona during the high solar insolation period of summer 2015. The approach was limited to twice daily fed-batch addition while accounting for ammonium-N preference in a background of nitrate-based algae growth media. Despite these limitations, growth achieved for a photobioreactor operated based on predicted metabolic nitrogen demand (PND) was comparable to 'CO2-on-demand' (CoD) for pH control. PND reduced CO2 usage to <10% of CoD control, where the reduced buffering resulted in much greater pH fluctuations due to daily variations in light availability, and a much lower and more consistent media alkalinity (5.73-5.79 mEq/L) as compared to the CoD control (6.51-8.49 mEq/L). While this effort illustrates the utility of feed-forward model-based control, it further illustrates the need for far more sophisticated 'real time' monitoring and modeling to accommodate the dynamic outdoor conditions. A need for improved analytics for accurate closure of nitrogen mass balance is also indicated.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)288-295
Number of pages8
JournalAlgal Research
Volume18
DOIs
StatePublished - Sep 1 2016

Fingerprint

Nannochloropsis
microalgae
algae
nitrogen
protons
culture media
nitrates
alkalinization
ammonium compounds
feeding methods
nitrogen metabolism
alkalinity
acidification
solar radiation
metabolism
monitoring
acids
summer
nutrients

All Science Journal Classification (ASJC) codes

  • Agronomy and Crop Science

Cite this

@article{6e3db4b993c04983a5369e4dc5e65545,
title = "A preliminary implementation of metabolic-based pH control to reduce CO2 usage in outdoor flat-panel photobioreactor cultivation of Nannochloropsis oceanica microalgae",
abstract = "A crucial challenge associated with high-density, commercial-scale, outdoor microalgal cultivation is maintaining pH stability without excessive use of CO2 buffering. This includes a media-dependent, intracellular metabolic proton imbalance leading to the alkalization or acidification of growth media that results when algae consume, respectively, nitrate or ammonium ions. Feeding these two nitrogen sources can theoretically achieve balanced proton metabolism as well as pH control that is economically more favorable as compared to CO2 buffering or acid/base addition. To accomplish this, a fed-batch nutrient feeding strategy must be adopted as a component of a model-based pH control system, particularly in the case of ammonium preference. This work represents a preliminary study of the challenges of implementing a nitrogen metabolism based open-loop pH control strategy in the challenging environment of an outdoor photobioreactor at the DOE-ATP3 testbed facility in Mesa, Arizona during the high solar insolation period of summer 2015. The approach was limited to twice daily fed-batch addition while accounting for ammonium-N preference in a background of nitrate-based algae growth media. Despite these limitations, growth achieved for a photobioreactor operated based on predicted metabolic nitrogen demand (PND) was comparable to 'CO2-on-demand' (CoD) for pH control. PND reduced CO2 usage to <10{\%} of CoD control, where the reduced buffering resulted in much greater pH fluctuations due to daily variations in light availability, and a much lower and more consistent media alkalinity (5.73-5.79 mEq/L) as compared to the CoD control (6.51-8.49 mEq/L). While this effort illustrates the utility of feed-forward model-based control, it further illustrates the need for far more sophisticated 'real time' monitoring and modeling to accommodate the dynamic outdoor conditions. A need for improved analytics for accurate closure of nitrogen mass balance is also indicated.",
author = "Jun Wang and Theresa Rosov and Pierre Wensel and John McGowen and Curtis, {Wayne R.}",
year = "2016",
month = "9",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1016/j.algal.2016.07.001",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "18",
pages = "288--295",
journal = "Algal Research",
issn = "2211-9264",
publisher = "Elsevier BV",

}

A preliminary implementation of metabolic-based pH control to reduce CO2 usage in outdoor flat-panel photobioreactor cultivation of Nannochloropsis oceanica microalgae. / Wang, Jun; Rosov, Theresa; Wensel, Pierre; McGowen, John; Curtis, Wayne R.

In: Algal Research, Vol. 18, 01.09.2016, p. 288-295.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - A preliminary implementation of metabolic-based pH control to reduce CO2 usage in outdoor flat-panel photobioreactor cultivation of Nannochloropsis oceanica microalgae

AU - Wang, Jun

AU - Rosov, Theresa

AU - Wensel, Pierre

AU - McGowen, John

AU - Curtis, Wayne R.

PY - 2016/9/1

Y1 - 2016/9/1

N2 - A crucial challenge associated with high-density, commercial-scale, outdoor microalgal cultivation is maintaining pH stability without excessive use of CO2 buffering. This includes a media-dependent, intracellular metabolic proton imbalance leading to the alkalization or acidification of growth media that results when algae consume, respectively, nitrate or ammonium ions. Feeding these two nitrogen sources can theoretically achieve balanced proton metabolism as well as pH control that is economically more favorable as compared to CO2 buffering or acid/base addition. To accomplish this, a fed-batch nutrient feeding strategy must be adopted as a component of a model-based pH control system, particularly in the case of ammonium preference. This work represents a preliminary study of the challenges of implementing a nitrogen metabolism based open-loop pH control strategy in the challenging environment of an outdoor photobioreactor at the DOE-ATP3 testbed facility in Mesa, Arizona during the high solar insolation period of summer 2015. The approach was limited to twice daily fed-batch addition while accounting for ammonium-N preference in a background of nitrate-based algae growth media. Despite these limitations, growth achieved for a photobioreactor operated based on predicted metabolic nitrogen demand (PND) was comparable to 'CO2-on-demand' (CoD) for pH control. PND reduced CO2 usage to <10% of CoD control, where the reduced buffering resulted in much greater pH fluctuations due to daily variations in light availability, and a much lower and more consistent media alkalinity (5.73-5.79 mEq/L) as compared to the CoD control (6.51-8.49 mEq/L). While this effort illustrates the utility of feed-forward model-based control, it further illustrates the need for far more sophisticated 'real time' monitoring and modeling to accommodate the dynamic outdoor conditions. A need for improved analytics for accurate closure of nitrogen mass balance is also indicated.

AB - A crucial challenge associated with high-density, commercial-scale, outdoor microalgal cultivation is maintaining pH stability without excessive use of CO2 buffering. This includes a media-dependent, intracellular metabolic proton imbalance leading to the alkalization or acidification of growth media that results when algae consume, respectively, nitrate or ammonium ions. Feeding these two nitrogen sources can theoretically achieve balanced proton metabolism as well as pH control that is economically more favorable as compared to CO2 buffering or acid/base addition. To accomplish this, a fed-batch nutrient feeding strategy must be adopted as a component of a model-based pH control system, particularly in the case of ammonium preference. This work represents a preliminary study of the challenges of implementing a nitrogen metabolism based open-loop pH control strategy in the challenging environment of an outdoor photobioreactor at the DOE-ATP3 testbed facility in Mesa, Arizona during the high solar insolation period of summer 2015. The approach was limited to twice daily fed-batch addition while accounting for ammonium-N preference in a background of nitrate-based algae growth media. Despite these limitations, growth achieved for a photobioreactor operated based on predicted metabolic nitrogen demand (PND) was comparable to 'CO2-on-demand' (CoD) for pH control. PND reduced CO2 usage to <10% of CoD control, where the reduced buffering resulted in much greater pH fluctuations due to daily variations in light availability, and a much lower and more consistent media alkalinity (5.73-5.79 mEq/L) as compared to the CoD control (6.51-8.49 mEq/L). While this effort illustrates the utility of feed-forward model-based control, it further illustrates the need for far more sophisticated 'real time' monitoring and modeling to accommodate the dynamic outdoor conditions. A need for improved analytics for accurate closure of nitrogen mass balance is also indicated.

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84977490449&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=84977490449&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1016/j.algal.2016.07.001

DO - 10.1016/j.algal.2016.07.001

M3 - Article

AN - SCOPUS:84977490449

VL - 18

SP - 288

EP - 295

JO - Algal Research

JF - Algal Research

SN - 2211-9264

ER -