Are the concepts of dynamic equilibrium and the thermodynamic criteria for spontaneity, nonspontaneity, and equilibrium compatible?

Lee Jonathan Silverberg, Lionel M. Raff

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

2 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Thermodynamic spontaneity-equilibrium criteria require that in a single-reaction system, reactions in either the forward or reverse direction at equilibrium be nonspontaneous. Conversely, the concept of dynamic equilibrium holds that forward and reverse reactions both occur at equal rates at equilibrium to the extent allowed by kinetic considerations. This paper discusses the resolution of this apparent conundrum. Qualitatively, it is argued that thermodynamics deals only with the macroscopic behavior of large systems, not with the microscopic details that lead to the observed macroscopic events. Since the observed events are measurable changes in the system composition without the necessity to do work on the system, any set of microscopic events that lead to the same macroscopic observations are compatible with thermodynamics. Quantitatively, it is shown that when considered statistically, thermodynamics shows that microscopic reactions in both forward and reverse directions are expected to occur at all points along the reaction coordinate provided only that both reactants and products are present. At equilibrium, the statistical treatment predicts that forward and reverse microscopic reactions have equal probability. Consequently, the concept of a dynamic equilibrium and the spontaneity-equilibrium constraints of thermodynamics are completely compatible.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)655-659
Number of pages5
JournalJournal of Chemical Education
Volume92
Issue number4
DOIs
StatePublished - Apr 14 2015

Fingerprint

spontaneity
Thermodynamics
event
Kinetics
Chemical analysis

All Science Journal Classification (ASJC) codes

  • Chemistry(all)
  • Education

Cite this

@article{03922129e0a84324b2d4359395a9b380,
title = "Are the concepts of dynamic equilibrium and the thermodynamic criteria for spontaneity, nonspontaneity, and equilibrium compatible?",
abstract = "Thermodynamic spontaneity-equilibrium criteria require that in a single-reaction system, reactions in either the forward or reverse direction at equilibrium be nonspontaneous. Conversely, the concept of dynamic equilibrium holds that forward and reverse reactions both occur at equal rates at equilibrium to the extent allowed by kinetic considerations. This paper discusses the resolution of this apparent conundrum. Qualitatively, it is argued that thermodynamics deals only with the macroscopic behavior of large systems, not with the microscopic details that lead to the observed macroscopic events. Since the observed events are measurable changes in the system composition without the necessity to do work on the system, any set of microscopic events that lead to the same macroscopic observations are compatible with thermodynamics. Quantitatively, it is shown that when considered statistically, thermodynamics shows that microscopic reactions in both forward and reverse directions are expected to occur at all points along the reaction coordinate provided only that both reactants and products are present. At equilibrium, the statistical treatment predicts that forward and reverse microscopic reactions have equal probability. Consequently, the concept of a dynamic equilibrium and the spontaneity-equilibrium constraints of thermodynamics are completely compatible.",
author = "Silverberg, {Lee Jonathan} and Raff, {Lionel M.}",
year = "2015",
month = "4",
day = "14",
doi = "10.1021/ed500660j",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "92",
pages = "655--659",
journal = "Journal of Chemical Education",
issn = "0021-9584",
publisher = "American Chemical Society",
number = "4",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Are the concepts of dynamic equilibrium and the thermodynamic criteria for spontaneity, nonspontaneity, and equilibrium compatible?

AU - Silverberg, Lee Jonathan

AU - Raff, Lionel M.

PY - 2015/4/14

Y1 - 2015/4/14

N2 - Thermodynamic spontaneity-equilibrium criteria require that in a single-reaction system, reactions in either the forward or reverse direction at equilibrium be nonspontaneous. Conversely, the concept of dynamic equilibrium holds that forward and reverse reactions both occur at equal rates at equilibrium to the extent allowed by kinetic considerations. This paper discusses the resolution of this apparent conundrum. Qualitatively, it is argued that thermodynamics deals only with the macroscopic behavior of large systems, not with the microscopic details that lead to the observed macroscopic events. Since the observed events are measurable changes in the system composition without the necessity to do work on the system, any set of microscopic events that lead to the same macroscopic observations are compatible with thermodynamics. Quantitatively, it is shown that when considered statistically, thermodynamics shows that microscopic reactions in both forward and reverse directions are expected to occur at all points along the reaction coordinate provided only that both reactants and products are present. At equilibrium, the statistical treatment predicts that forward and reverse microscopic reactions have equal probability. Consequently, the concept of a dynamic equilibrium and the spontaneity-equilibrium constraints of thermodynamics are completely compatible.

AB - Thermodynamic spontaneity-equilibrium criteria require that in a single-reaction system, reactions in either the forward or reverse direction at equilibrium be nonspontaneous. Conversely, the concept of dynamic equilibrium holds that forward and reverse reactions both occur at equal rates at equilibrium to the extent allowed by kinetic considerations. This paper discusses the resolution of this apparent conundrum. Qualitatively, it is argued that thermodynamics deals only with the macroscopic behavior of large systems, not with the microscopic details that lead to the observed macroscopic events. Since the observed events are measurable changes in the system composition without the necessity to do work on the system, any set of microscopic events that lead to the same macroscopic observations are compatible with thermodynamics. Quantitatively, it is shown that when considered statistically, thermodynamics shows that microscopic reactions in both forward and reverse directions are expected to occur at all points along the reaction coordinate provided only that both reactants and products are present. At equilibrium, the statistical treatment predicts that forward and reverse microscopic reactions have equal probability. Consequently, the concept of a dynamic equilibrium and the spontaneity-equilibrium constraints of thermodynamics are completely compatible.

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84927787032&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=84927787032&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1021/ed500660j

DO - 10.1021/ed500660j

M3 - Article

AN - SCOPUS:84927787032

VL - 92

SP - 655

EP - 659

JO - Journal of Chemical Education

JF - Journal of Chemical Education

SN - 0021-9584

IS - 4

ER -