Characterizing preferential flow in cracked paddy soils using computed tomography and breakthrough curve

Z. B. Zhang, X. Peng, H. Zhou, H. Lin, H. Sun

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

26 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Soil cracks generated in paddy fields may change soil structure and provide pathways for preferential flow. However, the quantitative relationship between soil cracks and preferential flow remain unclear in paddy soils. The objectives of this study were to (1) reveal the effect of soil cracking on soil structure and preferential flow, (2) find a quantitative relationship between characteristics of soil structure and preferential flow in two paddy fields. Two paddy fields, one cultivated for 20 years (YPF) and the other cultivated for more than 100 years (OPF), were subjected to either alternate flooding and drying (AFD) or continuous flooding (CF) (as a control) during rice growing season. Undisturbed soil columns (10cm in diameter and 20cm in height) were sampled in the four plots. Macropores (including cracks) were quantified using computed tomography (CT), and preferential flow was assessed by breakthrough curve (BTC). The results showed that the presence of soil cracks under the AFD increased average macropore length but decreased the number of macropores significantly (P<0.05), and it also changed macropore size distribution and macropore area density distribution with soil depth. The three-dimensional structures of soil cracks were complicated but can be quantified using CT. The BTCs were well fitted by the convection-dispersion model (CDE) as well as by the two-region (mobile-immobile) transport model. Quick breakthrough, long tail and asymmetrical shape of BTCs for all soil columns indicated the extensiveness of preferential flow in these paddy fields. The relationships between soil macropore features and solute dispersivity parameters (λ and λeff) were poor (P>0.05). Both the shape of BTCs and fitting parameters demonstrated that soil cracks (5.31-11.9cm depth) did not increase preferential flow because they did not perforate through the dense plow pan. Soil columns in the CF plots displayed a bit more preferential flow due to a deeper macropore distribution as compared with the AFD plots. While macropore features were different at the two paddy soils, the difference in preferential flow was reduced due to the presence of plow pan. This study demonstrates that soil cracks significantly affect macropore structure but their impact on preferential flow may be poor when they do not penetrate through the plow pan.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)53-65
Number of pages13
JournalSoil and Tillage Research
Volume146
Issue numberPA
DOIs
StatePublished - Mar 1 2015

Fingerprint

preferential flow
paddy soils
breakthrough curve
computed tomography
tomography
soil cracks
macropores
macropore
crack
plow pans
flooding
soil
soil structure
paddy field
paddies
drying
soil column
soil cracking
cracking
growing season

All Science Journal Classification (ASJC) codes

  • Agronomy and Crop Science
  • Soil Science
  • Earth-Surface Processes

Cite this

@article{ff138a4a5aea4d31a7e7d60aae394470,
title = "Characterizing preferential flow in cracked paddy soils using computed tomography and breakthrough curve",
abstract = "Soil cracks generated in paddy fields may change soil structure and provide pathways for preferential flow. However, the quantitative relationship between soil cracks and preferential flow remain unclear in paddy soils. The objectives of this study were to (1) reveal the effect of soil cracking on soil structure and preferential flow, (2) find a quantitative relationship between characteristics of soil structure and preferential flow in two paddy fields. Two paddy fields, one cultivated for 20 years (YPF) and the other cultivated for more than 100 years (OPF), were subjected to either alternate flooding and drying (AFD) or continuous flooding (CF) (as a control) during rice growing season. Undisturbed soil columns (10cm in diameter and 20cm in height) were sampled in the four plots. Macropores (including cracks) were quantified using computed tomography (CT), and preferential flow was assessed by breakthrough curve (BTC). The results showed that the presence of soil cracks under the AFD increased average macropore length but decreased the number of macropores significantly (P<0.05), and it also changed macropore size distribution and macropore area density distribution with soil depth. The three-dimensional structures of soil cracks were complicated but can be quantified using CT. The BTCs were well fitted by the convection-dispersion model (CDE) as well as by the two-region (mobile-immobile) transport model. Quick breakthrough, long tail and asymmetrical shape of BTCs for all soil columns indicated the extensiveness of preferential flow in these paddy fields. The relationships between soil macropore features and solute dispersivity parameters (λ and λeff) were poor (P>0.05). Both the shape of BTCs and fitting parameters demonstrated that soil cracks (5.31-11.9cm depth) did not increase preferential flow because they did not perforate through the dense plow pan. Soil columns in the CF plots displayed a bit more preferential flow due to a deeper macropore distribution as compared with the AFD plots. While macropore features were different at the two paddy soils, the difference in preferential flow was reduced due to the presence of plow pan. This study demonstrates that soil cracks significantly affect macropore structure but their impact on preferential flow may be poor when they do not penetrate through the plow pan.",
author = "Zhang, {Z. B.} and X. Peng and H. Zhou and H. Lin and H. Sun",
year = "2015",
month = "3",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1016/j.still.2014.05.016",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "146",
pages = "53--65",
journal = "Soil and Tillage Research",
issn = "0167-1987",
publisher = "Elsevier",
number = "PA",

}

Characterizing preferential flow in cracked paddy soils using computed tomography and breakthrough curve. / Zhang, Z. B.; Peng, X.; Zhou, H.; Lin, H.; Sun, H.

In: Soil and Tillage Research, Vol. 146, No. PA, 01.03.2015, p. 53-65.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - Characterizing preferential flow in cracked paddy soils using computed tomography and breakthrough curve

AU - Zhang, Z. B.

AU - Peng, X.

AU - Zhou, H.

AU - Lin, H.

AU - Sun, H.

PY - 2015/3/1

Y1 - 2015/3/1

N2 - Soil cracks generated in paddy fields may change soil structure and provide pathways for preferential flow. However, the quantitative relationship between soil cracks and preferential flow remain unclear in paddy soils. The objectives of this study were to (1) reveal the effect of soil cracking on soil structure and preferential flow, (2) find a quantitative relationship between characteristics of soil structure and preferential flow in two paddy fields. Two paddy fields, one cultivated for 20 years (YPF) and the other cultivated for more than 100 years (OPF), were subjected to either alternate flooding and drying (AFD) or continuous flooding (CF) (as a control) during rice growing season. Undisturbed soil columns (10cm in diameter and 20cm in height) were sampled in the four plots. Macropores (including cracks) were quantified using computed tomography (CT), and preferential flow was assessed by breakthrough curve (BTC). The results showed that the presence of soil cracks under the AFD increased average macropore length but decreased the number of macropores significantly (P<0.05), and it also changed macropore size distribution and macropore area density distribution with soil depth. The three-dimensional structures of soil cracks were complicated but can be quantified using CT. The BTCs were well fitted by the convection-dispersion model (CDE) as well as by the two-region (mobile-immobile) transport model. Quick breakthrough, long tail and asymmetrical shape of BTCs for all soil columns indicated the extensiveness of preferential flow in these paddy fields. The relationships between soil macropore features and solute dispersivity parameters (λ and λeff) were poor (P>0.05). Both the shape of BTCs and fitting parameters demonstrated that soil cracks (5.31-11.9cm depth) did not increase preferential flow because they did not perforate through the dense plow pan. Soil columns in the CF plots displayed a bit more preferential flow due to a deeper macropore distribution as compared with the AFD plots. While macropore features were different at the two paddy soils, the difference in preferential flow was reduced due to the presence of plow pan. This study demonstrates that soil cracks significantly affect macropore structure but their impact on preferential flow may be poor when they do not penetrate through the plow pan.

AB - Soil cracks generated in paddy fields may change soil structure and provide pathways for preferential flow. However, the quantitative relationship between soil cracks and preferential flow remain unclear in paddy soils. The objectives of this study were to (1) reveal the effect of soil cracking on soil structure and preferential flow, (2) find a quantitative relationship between characteristics of soil structure and preferential flow in two paddy fields. Two paddy fields, one cultivated for 20 years (YPF) and the other cultivated for more than 100 years (OPF), were subjected to either alternate flooding and drying (AFD) or continuous flooding (CF) (as a control) during rice growing season. Undisturbed soil columns (10cm in diameter and 20cm in height) were sampled in the four plots. Macropores (including cracks) were quantified using computed tomography (CT), and preferential flow was assessed by breakthrough curve (BTC). The results showed that the presence of soil cracks under the AFD increased average macropore length but decreased the number of macropores significantly (P<0.05), and it also changed macropore size distribution and macropore area density distribution with soil depth. The three-dimensional structures of soil cracks were complicated but can be quantified using CT. The BTCs were well fitted by the convection-dispersion model (CDE) as well as by the two-region (mobile-immobile) transport model. Quick breakthrough, long tail and asymmetrical shape of BTCs for all soil columns indicated the extensiveness of preferential flow in these paddy fields. The relationships between soil macropore features and solute dispersivity parameters (λ and λeff) were poor (P>0.05). Both the shape of BTCs and fitting parameters demonstrated that soil cracks (5.31-11.9cm depth) did not increase preferential flow because they did not perforate through the dense plow pan. Soil columns in the CF plots displayed a bit more preferential flow due to a deeper macropore distribution as compared with the AFD plots. While macropore features were different at the two paddy soils, the difference in preferential flow was reduced due to the presence of plow pan. This study demonstrates that soil cracks significantly affect macropore structure but their impact on preferential flow may be poor when they do not penetrate through the plow pan.

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84911376424&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=84911376424&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1016/j.still.2014.05.016

DO - 10.1016/j.still.2014.05.016

M3 - Article

AN - SCOPUS:84911376424

VL - 146

SP - 53

EP - 65

JO - Soil and Tillage Research

JF - Soil and Tillage Research

SN - 0167-1987

IS - PA

ER -