Comparison of reduced and conventional phase equilibrium calculations

S. E. Gorucu, Russell Taylor Johns

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingConference contribution

3 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Phase equilibrium calculations become computationally intensive in compositional simulation as the number of components and phases increase. Reduced methods were developed to address this problem where the binary interaction parameter (BIP) matrix is either approximated by spectral decomposition (Hendriks and van Bergen, 1992), or by using a two-parameter BIP formula (Li and Johns, 2006). Haugen and Beckner (2011) and Yan et al. (2011), however, recently stated that the spectral decomposition method, and by reference all reduced methods, are not as fast as previously reported in the literature. In this paper we present the first study that compares all eight reduced and conventional methods published to date using optimized code and compilers. The results show that the spectral decomposition method and its variants are not as fast as other reduced methods, and can be slower than the conventional approach when fewer than 20 components are used. The reason for the slow speed is the additional number of nested loops required in the code and the requirement that the code must allow for a variable number of eigenvalues. We show that the reduced method of Li and Johns (2006) and its variants, however, are significantly faster. Significant speed up in flash calculations is achieved for all fluids studied when more than six components are used. For example, for ten-component fluids, a speed up of 2 to 3 in the computational time for Newton-Raphson iterations are obtained compared to the conventional method based on minimization of Gibbs energy. We also demonstrate that the reduced method by Gorucu and Johns (2011, 2013), an offshoot of the Li and Johns (2006) reduced approach, is more robust than all other methods.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Title of host publicationSociety of Petroleum Engineers - SPE Reservoir Simulation Symposium 2013
Pages17-32
Number of pages16
StatePublished - Aug 8 2013
EventSPE Reservoir Simulation Symposium 2013 - The Woodlands, TX, United States
Duration: Feb 18 2013Feb 20 2013

Publication series

NameSociety of Petroleum Engineers - SPE Reservoir Simulation Symposium 2013
Volume1

Other

OtherSPE Reservoir Simulation Symposium 2013
CountryUnited States
CityThe Woodlands, TX
Period2/18/132/20/13

Fingerprint

Phase Equilibria
phase equilibrium
Phase equilibria
Decomposition
Spectral Decomposition
Fluids
Gibbs free energy
Spectral Methods
Decomposition Method
decomposition
Speedup
Binary
Fluid
Newton-Raphson
comparison
calculation
method
Number of Components
Flash
Interaction

All Science Journal Classification (ASJC) codes

  • Geochemistry and Petrology
  • Modeling and Simulation

Cite this

Gorucu, S. E., & Johns, R. T. (2013). Comparison of reduced and conventional phase equilibrium calculations. In Society of Petroleum Engineers - SPE Reservoir Simulation Symposium 2013 (pp. 17-32). (Society of Petroleum Engineers - SPE Reservoir Simulation Symposium 2013; Vol. 1).
Gorucu, S. E. ; Johns, Russell Taylor. / Comparison of reduced and conventional phase equilibrium calculations. Society of Petroleum Engineers - SPE Reservoir Simulation Symposium 2013. 2013. pp. 17-32 (Society of Petroleum Engineers - SPE Reservoir Simulation Symposium 2013).
@inproceedings{b0353d6f7ea948c8bcdb9b21211b4bb9,
title = "Comparison of reduced and conventional phase equilibrium calculations",
abstract = "Phase equilibrium calculations become computationally intensive in compositional simulation as the number of components and phases increase. Reduced methods were developed to address this problem where the binary interaction parameter (BIP) matrix is either approximated by spectral decomposition (Hendriks and van Bergen, 1992), or by using a two-parameter BIP formula (Li and Johns, 2006). Haugen and Beckner (2011) and Yan et al. (2011), however, recently stated that the spectral decomposition method, and by reference all reduced methods, are not as fast as previously reported in the literature. In this paper we present the first study that compares all eight reduced and conventional methods published to date using optimized code and compilers. The results show that the spectral decomposition method and its variants are not as fast as other reduced methods, and can be slower than the conventional approach when fewer than 20 components are used. The reason for the slow speed is the additional number of nested loops required in the code and the requirement that the code must allow for a variable number of eigenvalues. We show that the reduced method of Li and Johns (2006) and its variants, however, are significantly faster. Significant speed up in flash calculations is achieved for all fluids studied when more than six components are used. For example, for ten-component fluids, a speed up of 2 to 3 in the computational time for Newton-Raphson iterations are obtained compared to the conventional method based on minimization of Gibbs energy. We also demonstrate that the reduced method by Gorucu and Johns (2011, 2013), an offshoot of the Li and Johns (2006) reduced approach, is more robust than all other methods.",
author = "Gorucu, {S. E.} and Johns, {Russell Taylor}",
year = "2013",
month = "8",
day = "8",
language = "English (US)",
isbn = "9781627480246",
series = "Society of Petroleum Engineers - SPE Reservoir Simulation Symposium 2013",
pages = "17--32",
booktitle = "Society of Petroleum Engineers - SPE Reservoir Simulation Symposium 2013",

}

Gorucu, SE & Johns, RT 2013, Comparison of reduced and conventional phase equilibrium calculations. in Society of Petroleum Engineers - SPE Reservoir Simulation Symposium 2013. Society of Petroleum Engineers - SPE Reservoir Simulation Symposium 2013, vol. 1, pp. 17-32, SPE Reservoir Simulation Symposium 2013, The Woodlands, TX, United States, 2/18/13.

Comparison of reduced and conventional phase equilibrium calculations. / Gorucu, S. E.; Johns, Russell Taylor.

Society of Petroleum Engineers - SPE Reservoir Simulation Symposium 2013. 2013. p. 17-32 (Society of Petroleum Engineers - SPE Reservoir Simulation Symposium 2013; Vol. 1).

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingConference contribution

TY - GEN

T1 - Comparison of reduced and conventional phase equilibrium calculations

AU - Gorucu, S. E.

AU - Johns, Russell Taylor

PY - 2013/8/8

Y1 - 2013/8/8

N2 - Phase equilibrium calculations become computationally intensive in compositional simulation as the number of components and phases increase. Reduced methods were developed to address this problem where the binary interaction parameter (BIP) matrix is either approximated by spectral decomposition (Hendriks and van Bergen, 1992), or by using a two-parameter BIP formula (Li and Johns, 2006). Haugen and Beckner (2011) and Yan et al. (2011), however, recently stated that the spectral decomposition method, and by reference all reduced methods, are not as fast as previously reported in the literature. In this paper we present the first study that compares all eight reduced and conventional methods published to date using optimized code and compilers. The results show that the spectral decomposition method and its variants are not as fast as other reduced methods, and can be slower than the conventional approach when fewer than 20 components are used. The reason for the slow speed is the additional number of nested loops required in the code and the requirement that the code must allow for a variable number of eigenvalues. We show that the reduced method of Li and Johns (2006) and its variants, however, are significantly faster. Significant speed up in flash calculations is achieved for all fluids studied when more than six components are used. For example, for ten-component fluids, a speed up of 2 to 3 in the computational time for Newton-Raphson iterations are obtained compared to the conventional method based on minimization of Gibbs energy. We also demonstrate that the reduced method by Gorucu and Johns (2011, 2013), an offshoot of the Li and Johns (2006) reduced approach, is more robust than all other methods.

AB - Phase equilibrium calculations become computationally intensive in compositional simulation as the number of components and phases increase. Reduced methods were developed to address this problem where the binary interaction parameter (BIP) matrix is either approximated by spectral decomposition (Hendriks and van Bergen, 1992), or by using a two-parameter BIP formula (Li and Johns, 2006). Haugen and Beckner (2011) and Yan et al. (2011), however, recently stated that the spectral decomposition method, and by reference all reduced methods, are not as fast as previously reported in the literature. In this paper we present the first study that compares all eight reduced and conventional methods published to date using optimized code and compilers. The results show that the spectral decomposition method and its variants are not as fast as other reduced methods, and can be slower than the conventional approach when fewer than 20 components are used. The reason for the slow speed is the additional number of nested loops required in the code and the requirement that the code must allow for a variable number of eigenvalues. We show that the reduced method of Li and Johns (2006) and its variants, however, are significantly faster. Significant speed up in flash calculations is achieved for all fluids studied when more than six components are used. For example, for ten-component fluids, a speed up of 2 to 3 in the computational time for Newton-Raphson iterations are obtained compared to the conventional method based on minimization of Gibbs energy. We also demonstrate that the reduced method by Gorucu and Johns (2011, 2013), an offshoot of the Li and Johns (2006) reduced approach, is more robust than all other methods.

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84881047759&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=84881047759&partnerID=8YFLogxK

M3 - Conference contribution

AN - SCOPUS:84881047759

SN - 9781627480246

T3 - Society of Petroleum Engineers - SPE Reservoir Simulation Symposium 2013

SP - 17

EP - 32

BT - Society of Petroleum Engineers - SPE Reservoir Simulation Symposium 2013

ER -

Gorucu SE, Johns RT. Comparison of reduced and conventional phase equilibrium calculations. In Society of Petroleum Engineers - SPE Reservoir Simulation Symposium 2013. 2013. p. 17-32. (Society of Petroleum Engineers - SPE Reservoir Simulation Symposium 2013).