Early involvement of the mechanical contractor to improve design integration

A comparative case study

Research output: Contribution to conferencePaper

Abstract

As notable consumers of energy, with a tangible responsibility for clinical outcomes, healthcare facilities are at the forefront of sustainable design. Research correlates interdisciplinary teams with higher LEED rating and improved schedule performance, which favor more integrated organizational structures such as design-build. Specialty contractors, specifically the mechanical contractor, are becoming key participants in the early design phases of healthcare projects. This paper explores the relationships between early specialty contractor involvement in design and building system performance outcomes, using a comparative case study between design-build and CM at risk hospital projects. Due to similarities in size, scope, owner type and other factors in the selected cases, relationships are highlighted at the building system-level between the design responsibility offered to the mechanical contractor and project performance. Performance metrics under comparison in both cases include schedule and cost growth, safety statistics and projected yearly energy savings. The results indicate that tracking outcomes at the building system-level can assist in predicting project-level outcomes in a design-build organizational structure, suggesting connections between contractor design responsibility, HVAC system performance and jobsite accident rates.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages2564-2571
Number of pages8
StatePublished - Dec 1 2011
EventAnnual Conference of the Canadian Society for Civil Engineering 2011, CSCE 2011 - Ottawa, ON, Canada
Duration: Jun 14 2011Jun 17 2011

Other

OtherAnnual Conference of the Canadian Society for Civil Engineering 2011, CSCE 2011
CountryCanada
CityOttawa, ON
Period6/14/116/17/11

Fingerprint

Contractors
Energy conservation
Accidents
Statistics
Costs

All Science Journal Classification (ASJC) codes

  • Engineering(all)

Cite this

Franz, B. W., Leicht, R. M., & Riley, II, D. R. (2011). Early involvement of the mechanical contractor to improve design integration: A comparative case study. 2564-2571. Paper presented at Annual Conference of the Canadian Society for Civil Engineering 2011, CSCE 2011, Ottawa, ON, Canada.
Franz, Bryan W. ; Leicht, Robert Michael ; Riley, II, David R. / Early involvement of the mechanical contractor to improve design integration : A comparative case study. Paper presented at Annual Conference of the Canadian Society for Civil Engineering 2011, CSCE 2011, Ottawa, ON, Canada.8 p.
@conference{f42e6a315e334dbca44150a16c2d6411,
title = "Early involvement of the mechanical contractor to improve design integration: A comparative case study",
abstract = "As notable consumers of energy, with a tangible responsibility for clinical outcomes, healthcare facilities are at the forefront of sustainable design. Research correlates interdisciplinary teams with higher LEED rating and improved schedule performance, which favor more integrated organizational structures such as design-build. Specialty contractors, specifically the mechanical contractor, are becoming key participants in the early design phases of healthcare projects. This paper explores the relationships between early specialty contractor involvement in design and building system performance outcomes, using a comparative case study between design-build and CM at risk hospital projects. Due to similarities in size, scope, owner type and other factors in the selected cases, relationships are highlighted at the building system-level between the design responsibility offered to the mechanical contractor and project performance. Performance metrics under comparison in both cases include schedule and cost growth, safety statistics and projected yearly energy savings. The results indicate that tracking outcomes at the building system-level can assist in predicting project-level outcomes in a design-build organizational structure, suggesting connections between contractor design responsibility, HVAC system performance and jobsite accident rates.",
author = "Franz, {Bryan W.} and Leicht, {Robert Michael} and {Riley, II}, {David R.}",
year = "2011",
month = "12",
day = "1",
language = "English (US)",
pages = "2564--2571",
note = "Annual Conference of the Canadian Society for Civil Engineering 2011, CSCE 2011 ; Conference date: 14-06-2011 Through 17-06-2011",

}

Franz, BW, Leicht, RM & Riley, II, DR 2011, 'Early involvement of the mechanical contractor to improve design integration: A comparative case study' Paper presented at Annual Conference of the Canadian Society for Civil Engineering 2011, CSCE 2011, Ottawa, ON, Canada, 6/14/11 - 6/17/11, pp. 2564-2571.

Early involvement of the mechanical contractor to improve design integration : A comparative case study. / Franz, Bryan W.; Leicht, Robert Michael; Riley, II, David R.

2011. 2564-2571 Paper presented at Annual Conference of the Canadian Society for Civil Engineering 2011, CSCE 2011, Ottawa, ON, Canada.

Research output: Contribution to conferencePaper

TY - CONF

T1 - Early involvement of the mechanical contractor to improve design integration

T2 - A comparative case study

AU - Franz, Bryan W.

AU - Leicht, Robert Michael

AU - Riley, II, David R.

PY - 2011/12/1

Y1 - 2011/12/1

N2 - As notable consumers of energy, with a tangible responsibility for clinical outcomes, healthcare facilities are at the forefront of sustainable design. Research correlates interdisciplinary teams with higher LEED rating and improved schedule performance, which favor more integrated organizational structures such as design-build. Specialty contractors, specifically the mechanical contractor, are becoming key participants in the early design phases of healthcare projects. This paper explores the relationships between early specialty contractor involvement in design and building system performance outcomes, using a comparative case study between design-build and CM at risk hospital projects. Due to similarities in size, scope, owner type and other factors in the selected cases, relationships are highlighted at the building system-level between the design responsibility offered to the mechanical contractor and project performance. Performance metrics under comparison in both cases include schedule and cost growth, safety statistics and projected yearly energy savings. The results indicate that tracking outcomes at the building system-level can assist in predicting project-level outcomes in a design-build organizational structure, suggesting connections between contractor design responsibility, HVAC system performance and jobsite accident rates.

AB - As notable consumers of energy, with a tangible responsibility for clinical outcomes, healthcare facilities are at the forefront of sustainable design. Research correlates interdisciplinary teams with higher LEED rating and improved schedule performance, which favor more integrated organizational structures such as design-build. Specialty contractors, specifically the mechanical contractor, are becoming key participants in the early design phases of healthcare projects. This paper explores the relationships between early specialty contractor involvement in design and building system performance outcomes, using a comparative case study between design-build and CM at risk hospital projects. Due to similarities in size, scope, owner type and other factors in the selected cases, relationships are highlighted at the building system-level between the design responsibility offered to the mechanical contractor and project performance. Performance metrics under comparison in both cases include schedule and cost growth, safety statistics and projected yearly energy savings. The results indicate that tracking outcomes at the building system-level can assist in predicting project-level outcomes in a design-build organizational structure, suggesting connections between contractor design responsibility, HVAC system performance and jobsite accident rates.

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84855769576&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=84855769576&partnerID=8YFLogxK

M3 - Paper

SP - 2564

EP - 2571

ER -

Franz BW, Leicht RM, Riley, II DR. Early involvement of the mechanical contractor to improve design integration: A comparative case study. 2011. Paper presented at Annual Conference of the Canadian Society for Civil Engineering 2011, CSCE 2011, Ottawa, ON, Canada.