Efficacy and stability of integrating fungicide and cultivar resistance to manage fusarium head blight and deoxynivalenol in wheat

K. T. Willyerd, C. Li, L. V. Madden, C. A. Bradley, G. C. Bergstrom, L. E. Sweets, M. Mcmullen, J. K. Ransom, A. Grybauskas, L. Osborne, S. N. Wegulo, D. E. Hershman, K. Wise, W. W. Bockus, D. Groth, R. Dill-Macky, E. Milus, Paul Esker, K. D. Waxman, E. A. Adee & 3 others S. E. Ebelhar, B. G. Young, P. A. Paul

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

55 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Integration of host resistance and prothioconazole + tebuconazole fungicide application at anthesis to manage Fusarium head blight (FHB) and deoxynivalenol (DON) in wheat was evaluated using data from over 40 trials in 12 U.S. states. Means of FHB index (index) and DON from up to six resistance class-fungicide management combinations per trial (susceptible treated [S_TR] and untreated [S_UT]; moderately susceptible treated [MS_TR] and untreated [MS_UT]; moderately resistant treated [MR_TR] and untreated [MR_UT]) were used in multivariate meta-analyses, and mean log response ratios across trials were estimated and transformed to estimate mean percent control (C) due to the management combinations relative to S_UT. All combinations led to a significant reduction in index and DON (P < 0.001). MR_TR was the most effective combination, with a C of 76% for index and 71% for DON, followed by MS_TR (71 and 58%, respectively), MR_UT (54 and 51%, respectively), S_TR (53 and 39%, respectively), and MS_UT (43 and 30%, respectively). Calculations based on the principle of treatment independence showed that the combination of fungicide application and resistance was additive in terms of percent control for index and DON. Management combinations were ranked based on percent control relative to S_UT within each trial, and nonparametric analyses were performed to determine management combination stability across environments (trials) using the Kendall coefficient of concordance (W). There was a significant concordance of management combinations for both index and DON (P < 0.001), indicating a nonrandom ranking across environments and relatively low variability in the within-environment ranking of management combinations. MR_TR had the highest mean rank (best control relative to S_UT) and was one of the most stable management combinations across environments, with low rank stability variance (0.99 for index and 0.67 for DON). MS_UT had the lowest mean rank (poorest control) but was also one of the most stable management combinations. Based on Piepho's nonparametric rank-based variance homogeneity U test, there was an interaction of management combination and environment for index (P = 0.011) but not for DON (P = 0.147), indicating that the rank ordering for index depended somewhat on environment. In conclusion, although the magnitude of percent control will likely vary among environments, integrating a single tebuconazole + prothioconazole application at anthesis with cultivar resistance will be a more effective and stable management practice for both index and DON than either approach used alone.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)957-967
Number of pages11
JournalPlant disease
Volume96
Issue number7
DOIs
StatePublished - Jul 1 2012

Fingerprint

Fusarium head blight
deoxynivalenol
fungicides
wheat
cultivars
tebuconazole
pesticide application
flowering
fungicide resistance

All Science Journal Classification (ASJC) codes

  • Agronomy and Crop Science
  • Plant Science

Cite this

Willyerd, K. T., Li, C., Madden, L. V., Bradley, C. A., Bergstrom, G. C., Sweets, L. E., ... Paul, P. A. (2012). Efficacy and stability of integrating fungicide and cultivar resistance to manage fusarium head blight and deoxynivalenol in wheat. Plant disease, 96(7), 957-967. https://doi.org/10.1094/PDIS-09-11-0763
Willyerd, K. T. ; Li, C. ; Madden, L. V. ; Bradley, C. A. ; Bergstrom, G. C. ; Sweets, L. E. ; Mcmullen, M. ; Ransom, J. K. ; Grybauskas, A. ; Osborne, L. ; Wegulo, S. N. ; Hershman, D. E. ; Wise, K. ; Bockus, W. W. ; Groth, D. ; Dill-Macky, R. ; Milus, E. ; Esker, Paul ; Waxman, K. D. ; Adee, E. A. ; Ebelhar, S. E. ; Young, B. G. ; Paul, P. A. / Efficacy and stability of integrating fungicide and cultivar resistance to manage fusarium head blight and deoxynivalenol in wheat. In: Plant disease. 2012 ; Vol. 96, No. 7. pp. 957-967.
@article{7333fd8638c94505a4e51f99c2d113ef,
title = "Efficacy and stability of integrating fungicide and cultivar resistance to manage fusarium head blight and deoxynivalenol in wheat",
abstract = "Integration of host resistance and prothioconazole + tebuconazole fungicide application at anthesis to manage Fusarium head blight (FHB) and deoxynivalenol (DON) in wheat was evaluated using data from over 40 trials in 12 U.S. states. Means of FHB index (index) and DON from up to six resistance class-fungicide management combinations per trial (susceptible treated [S_TR] and untreated [S_UT]; moderately susceptible treated [MS_TR] and untreated [MS_UT]; moderately resistant treated [MR_TR] and untreated [MR_UT]) were used in multivariate meta-analyses, and mean log response ratios across trials were estimated and transformed to estimate mean percent control (C) due to the management combinations relative to S_UT. All combinations led to a significant reduction in index and DON (P < 0.001). MR_TR was the most effective combination, with a C of 76{\%} for index and 71{\%} for DON, followed by MS_TR (71 and 58{\%}, respectively), MR_UT (54 and 51{\%}, respectively), S_TR (53 and 39{\%}, respectively), and MS_UT (43 and 30{\%}, respectively). Calculations based on the principle of treatment independence showed that the combination of fungicide application and resistance was additive in terms of percent control for index and DON. Management combinations were ranked based on percent control relative to S_UT within each trial, and nonparametric analyses were performed to determine management combination stability across environments (trials) using the Kendall coefficient of concordance (W). There was a significant concordance of management combinations for both index and DON (P < 0.001), indicating a nonrandom ranking across environments and relatively low variability in the within-environment ranking of management combinations. MR_TR had the highest mean rank (best control relative to S_UT) and was one of the most stable management combinations across environments, with low rank stability variance (0.99 for index and 0.67 for DON). MS_UT had the lowest mean rank (poorest control) but was also one of the most stable management combinations. Based on Piepho's nonparametric rank-based variance homogeneity U test, there was an interaction of management combination and environment for index (P = 0.011) but not for DON (P = 0.147), indicating that the rank ordering for index depended somewhat on environment. In conclusion, although the magnitude of percent control will likely vary among environments, integrating a single tebuconazole + prothioconazole application at anthesis with cultivar resistance will be a more effective and stable management practice for both index and DON than either approach used alone.",
author = "Willyerd, {K. T.} and C. Li and Madden, {L. V.} and Bradley, {C. A.} and Bergstrom, {G. C.} and Sweets, {L. E.} and M. Mcmullen and Ransom, {J. K.} and A. Grybauskas and L. Osborne and Wegulo, {S. N.} and Hershman, {D. E.} and K. Wise and Bockus, {W. W.} and D. Groth and R. Dill-Macky and E. Milus and Paul Esker and Waxman, {K. D.} and Adee, {E. A.} and Ebelhar, {S. E.} and Young, {B. G.} and Paul, {P. A.}",
year = "2012",
month = "7",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1094/PDIS-09-11-0763",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "96",
pages = "957--967",
journal = "Plant Disease",
issn = "0191-2917",
publisher = "American Phytopathological Society",
number = "7",

}

Willyerd, KT, Li, C, Madden, LV, Bradley, CA, Bergstrom, GC, Sweets, LE, Mcmullen, M, Ransom, JK, Grybauskas, A, Osborne, L, Wegulo, SN, Hershman, DE, Wise, K, Bockus, WW, Groth, D, Dill-Macky, R, Milus, E, Esker, P, Waxman, KD, Adee, EA, Ebelhar, SE, Young, BG & Paul, PA 2012, 'Efficacy and stability of integrating fungicide and cultivar resistance to manage fusarium head blight and deoxynivalenol in wheat', Plant disease, vol. 96, no. 7, pp. 957-967. https://doi.org/10.1094/PDIS-09-11-0763

Efficacy and stability of integrating fungicide and cultivar resistance to manage fusarium head blight and deoxynivalenol in wheat. / Willyerd, K. T.; Li, C.; Madden, L. V.; Bradley, C. A.; Bergstrom, G. C.; Sweets, L. E.; Mcmullen, M.; Ransom, J. K.; Grybauskas, A.; Osborne, L.; Wegulo, S. N.; Hershman, D. E.; Wise, K.; Bockus, W. W.; Groth, D.; Dill-Macky, R.; Milus, E.; Esker, Paul; Waxman, K. D.; Adee, E. A.; Ebelhar, S. E.; Young, B. G.; Paul, P. A.

In: Plant disease, Vol. 96, No. 7, 01.07.2012, p. 957-967.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - Efficacy and stability of integrating fungicide and cultivar resistance to manage fusarium head blight and deoxynivalenol in wheat

AU - Willyerd, K. T.

AU - Li, C.

AU - Madden, L. V.

AU - Bradley, C. A.

AU - Bergstrom, G. C.

AU - Sweets, L. E.

AU - Mcmullen, M.

AU - Ransom, J. K.

AU - Grybauskas, A.

AU - Osborne, L.

AU - Wegulo, S. N.

AU - Hershman, D. E.

AU - Wise, K.

AU - Bockus, W. W.

AU - Groth, D.

AU - Dill-Macky, R.

AU - Milus, E.

AU - Esker, Paul

AU - Waxman, K. D.

AU - Adee, E. A.

AU - Ebelhar, S. E.

AU - Young, B. G.

AU - Paul, P. A.

PY - 2012/7/1

Y1 - 2012/7/1

N2 - Integration of host resistance and prothioconazole + tebuconazole fungicide application at anthesis to manage Fusarium head blight (FHB) and deoxynivalenol (DON) in wheat was evaluated using data from over 40 trials in 12 U.S. states. Means of FHB index (index) and DON from up to six resistance class-fungicide management combinations per trial (susceptible treated [S_TR] and untreated [S_UT]; moderately susceptible treated [MS_TR] and untreated [MS_UT]; moderately resistant treated [MR_TR] and untreated [MR_UT]) were used in multivariate meta-analyses, and mean log response ratios across trials were estimated and transformed to estimate mean percent control (C) due to the management combinations relative to S_UT. All combinations led to a significant reduction in index and DON (P < 0.001). MR_TR was the most effective combination, with a C of 76% for index and 71% for DON, followed by MS_TR (71 and 58%, respectively), MR_UT (54 and 51%, respectively), S_TR (53 and 39%, respectively), and MS_UT (43 and 30%, respectively). Calculations based on the principle of treatment independence showed that the combination of fungicide application and resistance was additive in terms of percent control for index and DON. Management combinations were ranked based on percent control relative to S_UT within each trial, and nonparametric analyses were performed to determine management combination stability across environments (trials) using the Kendall coefficient of concordance (W). There was a significant concordance of management combinations for both index and DON (P < 0.001), indicating a nonrandom ranking across environments and relatively low variability in the within-environment ranking of management combinations. MR_TR had the highest mean rank (best control relative to S_UT) and was one of the most stable management combinations across environments, with low rank stability variance (0.99 for index and 0.67 for DON). MS_UT had the lowest mean rank (poorest control) but was also one of the most stable management combinations. Based on Piepho's nonparametric rank-based variance homogeneity U test, there was an interaction of management combination and environment for index (P = 0.011) but not for DON (P = 0.147), indicating that the rank ordering for index depended somewhat on environment. In conclusion, although the magnitude of percent control will likely vary among environments, integrating a single tebuconazole + prothioconazole application at anthesis with cultivar resistance will be a more effective and stable management practice for both index and DON than either approach used alone.

AB - Integration of host resistance and prothioconazole + tebuconazole fungicide application at anthesis to manage Fusarium head blight (FHB) and deoxynivalenol (DON) in wheat was evaluated using data from over 40 trials in 12 U.S. states. Means of FHB index (index) and DON from up to six resistance class-fungicide management combinations per trial (susceptible treated [S_TR] and untreated [S_UT]; moderately susceptible treated [MS_TR] and untreated [MS_UT]; moderately resistant treated [MR_TR] and untreated [MR_UT]) were used in multivariate meta-analyses, and mean log response ratios across trials were estimated and transformed to estimate mean percent control (C) due to the management combinations relative to S_UT. All combinations led to a significant reduction in index and DON (P < 0.001). MR_TR was the most effective combination, with a C of 76% for index and 71% for DON, followed by MS_TR (71 and 58%, respectively), MR_UT (54 and 51%, respectively), S_TR (53 and 39%, respectively), and MS_UT (43 and 30%, respectively). Calculations based on the principle of treatment independence showed that the combination of fungicide application and resistance was additive in terms of percent control for index and DON. Management combinations were ranked based on percent control relative to S_UT within each trial, and nonparametric analyses were performed to determine management combination stability across environments (trials) using the Kendall coefficient of concordance (W). There was a significant concordance of management combinations for both index and DON (P < 0.001), indicating a nonrandom ranking across environments and relatively low variability in the within-environment ranking of management combinations. MR_TR had the highest mean rank (best control relative to S_UT) and was one of the most stable management combinations across environments, with low rank stability variance (0.99 for index and 0.67 for DON). MS_UT had the lowest mean rank (poorest control) but was also one of the most stable management combinations. Based on Piepho's nonparametric rank-based variance homogeneity U test, there was an interaction of management combination and environment for index (P = 0.011) but not for DON (P = 0.147), indicating that the rank ordering for index depended somewhat on environment. In conclusion, although the magnitude of percent control will likely vary among environments, integrating a single tebuconazole + prothioconazole application at anthesis with cultivar resistance will be a more effective and stable management practice for both index and DON than either approach used alone.

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84863744514&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=84863744514&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1094/PDIS-09-11-0763

DO - 10.1094/PDIS-09-11-0763

M3 - Article

VL - 96

SP - 957

EP - 967

JO - Plant Disease

JF - Plant Disease

SN - 0191-2917

IS - 7

ER -