Extending rights' reach: Constitutions, private law, and judicial power

Research output: Book/ReportBook

Abstract

Constitutional rights protect individuals against government overreaching, but that is not all they do. In different ways and to different degrees, constitutional rights also regulate legal relations among private parties in most legal systems. In other words, rights can have not only a vertical effect, within the hierarchical relationship between citizen and state, but also a horizontal one, on the citizen-to-citizen relationships otherwise governed by private law. In every constitutional system with judicially enforceable constitutional rights, courts must make choices about whether, when, and how to give those rights horizontal effect. This book is about how different courts make those choices, and about the consequences that they have. The doctrines that courts build to manage the horizontal effect of rights speak to the most fundamental issues that constitutional systems address, about the nature of rights and of constitutionalism itself. These doctrines can also entrench or enhance judicial power, but in very different ways depending on the legal system. This book offers three case studies, of Germany, the United States, and Canada. For each, it offers a detailed account of the horizontal effect jurisprudence of its apex court-not in isolation, but as a central feature of a broader account of that country's constitutional development. The case studies show how the choices courts make about horizontal rights reflect existing normative and political realities and, over time, help to shape new ones.

Original languageEnglish (US)
PublisherOxford University Press
Number of pages250
ISBN (Print)9780190682910
DOIs
StatePublished - Apr 19 2018

Fingerprint

judicial power
private law
constitution
citizen
legal system
doctrine
right to speak
constitutionalism
jurisprudence
social isolation
Canada

All Science Journal Classification (ASJC) codes

  • Social Sciences(all)

Cite this

@book{e2ebd44ffa8c4745bcca2243c363a20a,
title = "Extending rights' reach: Constitutions, private law, and judicial power",
abstract = "Constitutional rights protect individuals against government overreaching, but that is not all they do. In different ways and to different degrees, constitutional rights also regulate legal relations among private parties in most legal systems. In other words, rights can have not only a vertical effect, within the hierarchical relationship between citizen and state, but also a horizontal one, on the citizen-to-citizen relationships otherwise governed by private law. In every constitutional system with judicially enforceable constitutional rights, courts must make choices about whether, when, and how to give those rights horizontal effect. This book is about how different courts make those choices, and about the consequences that they have. The doctrines that courts build to manage the horizontal effect of rights speak to the most fundamental issues that constitutional systems address, about the nature of rights and of constitutionalism itself. These doctrines can also entrench or enhance judicial power, but in very different ways depending on the legal system. This book offers three case studies, of Germany, the United States, and Canada. For each, it offers a detailed account of the horizontal effect jurisprudence of its apex court-not in isolation, but as a central feature of a broader account of that country's constitutional development. The case studies show how the choices courts make about horizontal rights reflect existing normative and political realities and, over time, help to shape new ones.",
author = "Mathews, {Judkins Cooper}",
year = "2018",
month = "4",
day = "19",
doi = "10.1093/oso/9780190682910.001.0001",
language = "English (US)",
isbn = "9780190682910",
publisher = "Oxford University Press",
address = "United Kingdom",

}

Extending rights' reach : Constitutions, private law, and judicial power. / Mathews, Judkins Cooper.

Oxford University Press, 2018. 250 p.

Research output: Book/ReportBook

TY - BOOK

T1 - Extending rights' reach

T2 - Constitutions, private law, and judicial power

AU - Mathews, Judkins Cooper

PY - 2018/4/19

Y1 - 2018/4/19

N2 - Constitutional rights protect individuals against government overreaching, but that is not all they do. In different ways and to different degrees, constitutional rights also regulate legal relations among private parties in most legal systems. In other words, rights can have not only a vertical effect, within the hierarchical relationship between citizen and state, but also a horizontal one, on the citizen-to-citizen relationships otherwise governed by private law. In every constitutional system with judicially enforceable constitutional rights, courts must make choices about whether, when, and how to give those rights horizontal effect. This book is about how different courts make those choices, and about the consequences that they have. The doctrines that courts build to manage the horizontal effect of rights speak to the most fundamental issues that constitutional systems address, about the nature of rights and of constitutionalism itself. These doctrines can also entrench or enhance judicial power, but in very different ways depending on the legal system. This book offers three case studies, of Germany, the United States, and Canada. For each, it offers a detailed account of the horizontal effect jurisprudence of its apex court-not in isolation, but as a central feature of a broader account of that country's constitutional development. The case studies show how the choices courts make about horizontal rights reflect existing normative and political realities and, over time, help to shape new ones.

AB - Constitutional rights protect individuals against government overreaching, but that is not all they do. In different ways and to different degrees, constitutional rights also regulate legal relations among private parties in most legal systems. In other words, rights can have not only a vertical effect, within the hierarchical relationship between citizen and state, but also a horizontal one, on the citizen-to-citizen relationships otherwise governed by private law. In every constitutional system with judicially enforceable constitutional rights, courts must make choices about whether, when, and how to give those rights horizontal effect. This book is about how different courts make those choices, and about the consequences that they have. The doctrines that courts build to manage the horizontal effect of rights speak to the most fundamental issues that constitutional systems address, about the nature of rights and of constitutionalism itself. These doctrines can also entrench or enhance judicial power, but in very different ways depending on the legal system. This book offers three case studies, of Germany, the United States, and Canada. For each, it offers a detailed account of the horizontal effect jurisprudence of its apex court-not in isolation, but as a central feature of a broader account of that country's constitutional development. The case studies show how the choices courts make about horizontal rights reflect existing normative and political realities and, over time, help to shape new ones.

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85052328176&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=85052328176&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1093/oso/9780190682910.001.0001

DO - 10.1093/oso/9780190682910.001.0001

M3 - Book

AN - SCOPUS:85052328176

SN - 9780190682910

BT - Extending rights' reach

PB - Oxford University Press

ER -