Extreme-velocity quasar outflows and the role of X-ray shielding

F. Hamann, G. Chartas, S. McGraw, P. Rodriguez Hidalgo, J. Shields, D. Capellupo, Jane Camilla Charlton, Michael Eracleous

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

47 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Quasar accretion disc winds observed via broad absorption lines (BALs) in the UV produce strong continuous absorption in X-rays. The X-ray absorber is believed to serve critically as a radiative shield to keep the outflow ionizations low enough for radiative driving. However, previous studies have shown that 'mini-BAL' and narrow absorption line (NAL) outflows have dramatically less X-ray absorption than BALs. Here, we examine X-ray and rest-frame UV spectra of eight mini-BAL quasars with outflow speeds in the range 0.1-0.2c to test the hypothesis that these extreme speeds require a strong shield.We find that theX-ray absorption is weak or moderate, with neutral-equivalent column densities NH <few×1022 cm-2, consistent with mini-BALs at lower speeds. We use photoionization models to show that the amount of shielding consistent with our data is too weak to control the outflow ionizations and, therefore, it is not important for the acceleration. Shielding in complex geometries also seems unlikely because the alleged shield would need to extinguish the ionizing far-UV flux while avoiding detection in X-rays and the near-UV.We argue that the outflow ionizations are kept moderate, instead, by high gas densities in small clouds. If the mini-BALs form at radial distances of the order of R ~ 2 pc from the central quasar (broadly consistent with theoretical models and with the mini-BAL variabilities observed here and in previous work), and the total column densities in the mini-BAL gas are NH {less-than or approximate} 1021 cm-2, then the total radial extent of outflow clouds is only δRclouds {less-than or approximate} 3 × 1013 cm in cases of no/weak shielding or δRclouds {less-than or approximate} 3 × 1014 cm behind the maximum shield allowed by our data. This implies radial filling factorsδRclouds/R {less-than or approximate} 5 × 10-6 or {less-than or approximate}5 × 10-5 for the unshielded or maximally shielded cases, respectively. Compared to the transverse sizes {greater-than or approximate}8 × 1015 cm (based on measured line depths), the outflows have shapes like thin 'pancakes' viewed face-on, or they occupy larger volumes like a spray of many dense clouds with a small volume filling factor. These results favour models with magnetic confinement in magnetic disc winds. To the extent that BALs, mini-BALs and NALs probe the same general outflow phenomenon, our result for dense substructures should apply to all three outflow types.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)133-148
Number of pages16
JournalMonthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society
Volume435
Issue number1
DOIs
StatePublished - Oct 1 2013

Fingerprint

quasars
shielding
outflow
x rays
shield
ionization
magnetic disks
gas density
substructures
gas
accretion disks
spray
low speed
sprayers
photoionization
absorbers
rays
accretion
probe

All Science Journal Classification (ASJC) codes

  • Astronomy and Astrophysics
  • Space and Planetary Science

Cite this

Hamann, F., Chartas, G., McGraw, S., Rodriguez Hidalgo, P., Shields, J., Capellupo, D., ... Eracleous, M. (2013). Extreme-velocity quasar outflows and the role of X-ray shielding. Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society, 435(1), 133-148. https://doi.org/10.1093/mnras/stt1231
Hamann, F. ; Chartas, G. ; McGraw, S. ; Rodriguez Hidalgo, P. ; Shields, J. ; Capellupo, D. ; Charlton, Jane Camilla ; Eracleous, Michael. / Extreme-velocity quasar outflows and the role of X-ray shielding. In: Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society. 2013 ; Vol. 435, No. 1. pp. 133-148.
@article{850d5aaf0258418b82c087425e848b7f,
title = "Extreme-velocity quasar outflows and the role of X-ray shielding",
abstract = "Quasar accretion disc winds observed via broad absorption lines (BALs) in the UV produce strong continuous absorption in X-rays. The X-ray absorber is believed to serve critically as a radiative shield to keep the outflow ionizations low enough for radiative driving. However, previous studies have shown that 'mini-BAL' and narrow absorption line (NAL) outflows have dramatically less X-ray absorption than BALs. Here, we examine X-ray and rest-frame UV spectra of eight mini-BAL quasars with outflow speeds in the range 0.1-0.2c to test the hypothesis that these extreme speeds require a strong shield.We find that theX-ray absorption is weak or moderate, with neutral-equivalent column densities NH 22 cm-2, consistent with mini-BALs at lower speeds. We use photoionization models to show that the amount of shielding consistent with our data is too weak to control the outflow ionizations and, therefore, it is not important for the acceleration. Shielding in complex geometries also seems unlikely because the alleged shield would need to extinguish the ionizing far-UV flux while avoiding detection in X-rays and the near-UV.We argue that the outflow ionizations are kept moderate, instead, by high gas densities in small clouds. If the mini-BALs form at radial distances of the order of R ~ 2 pc from the central quasar (broadly consistent with theoretical models and with the mini-BAL variabilities observed here and in previous work), and the total column densities in the mini-BAL gas are NH {less-than or approximate} 1021 cm-2, then the total radial extent of outflow clouds is only δRclouds {less-than or approximate} 3 × 1013 cm in cases of no/weak shielding or δRclouds {less-than or approximate} 3 × 1014 cm behind the maximum shield allowed by our data. This implies radial filling factorsδRclouds/R {less-than or approximate} 5 × 10-6 or {less-than or approximate}5 × 10-5 for the unshielded or maximally shielded cases, respectively. Compared to the transverse sizes {greater-than or approximate}8 × 1015 cm (based on measured line depths), the outflows have shapes like thin 'pancakes' viewed face-on, or they occupy larger volumes like a spray of many dense clouds with a small volume filling factor. These results favour models with magnetic confinement in magnetic disc winds. To the extent that BALs, mini-BALs and NALs probe the same general outflow phenomenon, our result for dense substructures should apply to all three outflow types.",
author = "F. Hamann and G. Chartas and S. McGraw and {Rodriguez Hidalgo}, P. and J. Shields and D. Capellupo and Charlton, {Jane Camilla} and Michael Eracleous",
year = "2013",
month = "10",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1093/mnras/stt1231",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "435",
pages = "133--148",
journal = "Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society",
issn = "0035-8711",
publisher = "Oxford University Press",
number = "1",

}

Hamann, F, Chartas, G, McGraw, S, Rodriguez Hidalgo, P, Shields, J, Capellupo, D, Charlton, JC & Eracleous, M 2013, 'Extreme-velocity quasar outflows and the role of X-ray shielding', Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society, vol. 435, no. 1, pp. 133-148. https://doi.org/10.1093/mnras/stt1231

Extreme-velocity quasar outflows and the role of X-ray shielding. / Hamann, F.; Chartas, G.; McGraw, S.; Rodriguez Hidalgo, P.; Shields, J.; Capellupo, D.; Charlton, Jane Camilla; Eracleous, Michael.

In: Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society, Vol. 435, No. 1, 01.10.2013, p. 133-148.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - Extreme-velocity quasar outflows and the role of X-ray shielding

AU - Hamann, F.

AU - Chartas, G.

AU - McGraw, S.

AU - Rodriguez Hidalgo, P.

AU - Shields, J.

AU - Capellupo, D.

AU - Charlton, Jane Camilla

AU - Eracleous, Michael

PY - 2013/10/1

Y1 - 2013/10/1

N2 - Quasar accretion disc winds observed via broad absorption lines (BALs) in the UV produce strong continuous absorption in X-rays. The X-ray absorber is believed to serve critically as a radiative shield to keep the outflow ionizations low enough for radiative driving. However, previous studies have shown that 'mini-BAL' and narrow absorption line (NAL) outflows have dramatically less X-ray absorption than BALs. Here, we examine X-ray and rest-frame UV spectra of eight mini-BAL quasars with outflow speeds in the range 0.1-0.2c to test the hypothesis that these extreme speeds require a strong shield.We find that theX-ray absorption is weak or moderate, with neutral-equivalent column densities NH 22 cm-2, consistent with mini-BALs at lower speeds. We use photoionization models to show that the amount of shielding consistent with our data is too weak to control the outflow ionizations and, therefore, it is not important for the acceleration. Shielding in complex geometries also seems unlikely because the alleged shield would need to extinguish the ionizing far-UV flux while avoiding detection in X-rays and the near-UV.We argue that the outflow ionizations are kept moderate, instead, by high gas densities in small clouds. If the mini-BALs form at radial distances of the order of R ~ 2 pc from the central quasar (broadly consistent with theoretical models and with the mini-BAL variabilities observed here and in previous work), and the total column densities in the mini-BAL gas are NH {less-than or approximate} 1021 cm-2, then the total radial extent of outflow clouds is only δRclouds {less-than or approximate} 3 × 1013 cm in cases of no/weak shielding or δRclouds {less-than or approximate} 3 × 1014 cm behind the maximum shield allowed by our data. This implies radial filling factorsδRclouds/R {less-than or approximate} 5 × 10-6 or {less-than or approximate}5 × 10-5 for the unshielded or maximally shielded cases, respectively. Compared to the transverse sizes {greater-than or approximate}8 × 1015 cm (based on measured line depths), the outflows have shapes like thin 'pancakes' viewed face-on, or they occupy larger volumes like a spray of many dense clouds with a small volume filling factor. These results favour models with magnetic confinement in magnetic disc winds. To the extent that BALs, mini-BALs and NALs probe the same general outflow phenomenon, our result for dense substructures should apply to all three outflow types.

AB - Quasar accretion disc winds observed via broad absorption lines (BALs) in the UV produce strong continuous absorption in X-rays. The X-ray absorber is believed to serve critically as a radiative shield to keep the outflow ionizations low enough for radiative driving. However, previous studies have shown that 'mini-BAL' and narrow absorption line (NAL) outflows have dramatically less X-ray absorption than BALs. Here, we examine X-ray and rest-frame UV spectra of eight mini-BAL quasars with outflow speeds in the range 0.1-0.2c to test the hypothesis that these extreme speeds require a strong shield.We find that theX-ray absorption is weak or moderate, with neutral-equivalent column densities NH 22 cm-2, consistent with mini-BALs at lower speeds. We use photoionization models to show that the amount of shielding consistent with our data is too weak to control the outflow ionizations and, therefore, it is not important for the acceleration. Shielding in complex geometries also seems unlikely because the alleged shield would need to extinguish the ionizing far-UV flux while avoiding detection in X-rays and the near-UV.We argue that the outflow ionizations are kept moderate, instead, by high gas densities in small clouds. If the mini-BALs form at radial distances of the order of R ~ 2 pc from the central quasar (broadly consistent with theoretical models and with the mini-BAL variabilities observed here and in previous work), and the total column densities in the mini-BAL gas are NH {less-than or approximate} 1021 cm-2, then the total radial extent of outflow clouds is only δRclouds {less-than or approximate} 3 × 1013 cm in cases of no/weak shielding or δRclouds {less-than or approximate} 3 × 1014 cm behind the maximum shield allowed by our data. This implies radial filling factorsδRclouds/R {less-than or approximate} 5 × 10-6 or {less-than or approximate}5 × 10-5 for the unshielded or maximally shielded cases, respectively. Compared to the transverse sizes {greater-than or approximate}8 × 1015 cm (based on measured line depths), the outflows have shapes like thin 'pancakes' viewed face-on, or they occupy larger volumes like a spray of many dense clouds with a small volume filling factor. These results favour models with magnetic confinement in magnetic disc winds. To the extent that BALs, mini-BALs and NALs probe the same general outflow phenomenon, our result for dense substructures should apply to all three outflow types.

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84885153426&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=84885153426&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1093/mnras/stt1231

DO - 10.1093/mnras/stt1231

M3 - Article

VL - 435

SP - 133

EP - 148

JO - Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society

JF - Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society

SN - 0035-8711

IS - 1

ER -

Hamann F, Chartas G, McGraw S, Rodriguez Hidalgo P, Shields J, Capellupo D et al. Extreme-velocity quasar outflows and the role of X-ray shielding. Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society. 2013 Oct 1;435(1):133-148. https://doi.org/10.1093/mnras/stt1231