Generative imitation, strategic distancing and optimal distinctiveness during the growth, decline and stabilization of Silicon Alley

Raghu B. Garud, Theresa K. Lant, Henri A. Schildt

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

We embrace a cultural perspective on entrepreneurship to examine the performative relationship between entrepreneurial narratives and the field discourse that unfolded during the emergence of the ‘new media’ field in New York city that came to be known as ‘Silicon Alley’. During growth, the accumulation of projective entrepreneurial narratives generated a field discourse from which entrepreneurs drew. However, because of the hype generated and the implementation challenges encountered by the ventures, the expectations set by the entrepreneurs remained unrealized, thereby leading to failures. The loss of legitimacy that accrued to these ventures spread to others through the cultural symbols shared by the ventures, which led to the collapse of the field. Opportunities based on cultural symbols considered valuable during early stages now became worthless. The Silicon Alley field eventually stabilized as entrepreneurs offered revised narratives to generate renewed growth. Based on these dynamics, we introduce generative imitation and strategic distancing as narrative-discursive possibilities to complement the notion of optimal distinctiveness. We propose that optimal distinctiveness best describes narrative-discursive possibilities and efforts when fields have stabilized, whereas generative imitation and strategic distancing better describe possibilities and efforts during growth and decline periods respectively.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)187-213
Number of pages27
JournalInnovation: Management, Policy and Practice
Volume21
Issue number1
DOIs
StatePublished - Jan 2 2019

Fingerprint

Stabilization
Silicon
Imitation
Distinctiveness
Entrepreneurs
Venture
Symbol
Discourse

All Science Journal Classification (ASJC) codes

  • Management of Technology and Innovation

Cite this

@article{5314f0f40aa14750a47c866d76a30582,
title = "Generative imitation, strategic distancing and optimal distinctiveness during the growth, decline and stabilization of Silicon Alley",
abstract = "We embrace a cultural perspective on entrepreneurship to examine the performative relationship between entrepreneurial narratives and the field discourse that unfolded during the emergence of the ‘new media’ field in New York city that came to be known as ‘Silicon Alley’. During growth, the accumulation of projective entrepreneurial narratives generated a field discourse from which entrepreneurs drew. However, because of the hype generated and the implementation challenges encountered by the ventures, the expectations set by the entrepreneurs remained unrealized, thereby leading to failures. The loss of legitimacy that accrued to these ventures spread to others through the cultural symbols shared by the ventures, which led to the collapse of the field. Opportunities based on cultural symbols considered valuable during early stages now became worthless. The Silicon Alley field eventually stabilized as entrepreneurs offered revised narratives to generate renewed growth. Based on these dynamics, we introduce generative imitation and strategic distancing as narrative-discursive possibilities to complement the notion of optimal distinctiveness. We propose that optimal distinctiveness best describes narrative-discursive possibilities and efforts when fields have stabilized, whereas generative imitation and strategic distancing better describe possibilities and efforts during growth and decline periods respectively.",
author = "Garud, {Raghu B.} and Lant, {Theresa K.} and Schildt, {Henri A.}",
year = "2019",
month = "1",
day = "2",
doi = "10.1080/14479338.2018.1465822",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "21",
pages = "187--213",
journal = "Innovation: Management, Policy and Practice",
issn = "1447-9338",
publisher = "eContent Management Pty Ltd",
number = "1",

}

Generative imitation, strategic distancing and optimal distinctiveness during the growth, decline and stabilization of Silicon Alley. / Garud, Raghu B.; Lant, Theresa K.; Schildt, Henri A.

In: Innovation: Management, Policy and Practice, Vol. 21, No. 1, 02.01.2019, p. 187-213.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - Generative imitation, strategic distancing and optimal distinctiveness during the growth, decline and stabilization of Silicon Alley

AU - Garud, Raghu B.

AU - Lant, Theresa K.

AU - Schildt, Henri A.

PY - 2019/1/2

Y1 - 2019/1/2

N2 - We embrace a cultural perspective on entrepreneurship to examine the performative relationship between entrepreneurial narratives and the field discourse that unfolded during the emergence of the ‘new media’ field in New York city that came to be known as ‘Silicon Alley’. During growth, the accumulation of projective entrepreneurial narratives generated a field discourse from which entrepreneurs drew. However, because of the hype generated and the implementation challenges encountered by the ventures, the expectations set by the entrepreneurs remained unrealized, thereby leading to failures. The loss of legitimacy that accrued to these ventures spread to others through the cultural symbols shared by the ventures, which led to the collapse of the field. Opportunities based on cultural symbols considered valuable during early stages now became worthless. The Silicon Alley field eventually stabilized as entrepreneurs offered revised narratives to generate renewed growth. Based on these dynamics, we introduce generative imitation and strategic distancing as narrative-discursive possibilities to complement the notion of optimal distinctiveness. We propose that optimal distinctiveness best describes narrative-discursive possibilities and efforts when fields have stabilized, whereas generative imitation and strategic distancing better describe possibilities and efforts during growth and decline periods respectively.

AB - We embrace a cultural perspective on entrepreneurship to examine the performative relationship between entrepreneurial narratives and the field discourse that unfolded during the emergence of the ‘new media’ field in New York city that came to be known as ‘Silicon Alley’. During growth, the accumulation of projective entrepreneurial narratives generated a field discourse from which entrepreneurs drew. However, because of the hype generated and the implementation challenges encountered by the ventures, the expectations set by the entrepreneurs remained unrealized, thereby leading to failures. The loss of legitimacy that accrued to these ventures spread to others through the cultural symbols shared by the ventures, which led to the collapse of the field. Opportunities based on cultural symbols considered valuable during early stages now became worthless. The Silicon Alley field eventually stabilized as entrepreneurs offered revised narratives to generate renewed growth. Based on these dynamics, we introduce generative imitation and strategic distancing as narrative-discursive possibilities to complement the notion of optimal distinctiveness. We propose that optimal distinctiveness best describes narrative-discursive possibilities and efforts when fields have stabilized, whereas generative imitation and strategic distancing better describe possibilities and efforts during growth and decline periods respectively.

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85047985048&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=85047985048&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1080/14479338.2018.1465822

DO - 10.1080/14479338.2018.1465822

M3 - Article

VL - 21

SP - 187

EP - 213

JO - Innovation: Management, Policy and Practice

JF - Innovation: Management, Policy and Practice

SN - 1447-9338

IS - 1

ER -