Implications of basement rock alteration in the Nankai Trough, Japan for subduction megathrust slip behavior

Matt J. Ikari, Frederike K. Wilckens, Demian M. Saffer

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

The Nankai Trough is an exceptionally well-studied convergent margin known to host damaging megathrust earthquakes as well as various forms of slow fault slip. Outcrop studies of exhumed analogues for the modern subduction thrust, as well as seismic reflection images of the active subduction zone, suggest that the basaltic basement participates in plate-boundary shearing at depths of a few km and greater. We obtained altered basaltic upper basement from the modern Nankai Trough seaward of the trench, recovered by drilling on IODP Expedition 333. We performed laboratory friction experiments on bare surfaces and gouge powders of this material, in addition to and in combination with other materials for comparison. The altered basalt exhibits predominantly velocity-strengthening frictional behavior, indicating a tendency for stable slip. For bare surface experiments, few instances of velocity-weakening friction occur and are restricted to slip rates of <10 6 m/s. Thin sections and XRD analyses of the starting material indicate that the velocity-strengthening behavior is likely associated with the presence of clay minerals, mostly Mg-smectite, which coat the rims of larger, stronger grains. Based our friction data, we suggest that in addition to creep the altered Nankai basalts may also allow the possibility of slow slip events for two reasons: (1) velocity-weakening friction may be expected at low slip rates, but velocity-strengthening at higher rates will damp any potential slip instabilities; and (2) based on a critical stiffness criterion for accelerating (stable) slip, SSEs are capable of nucleating in the altered Nankai basalt despite velocity-strengthening friction. In light of these observations, and given the depth at which altered basement appears to be incorporated along the plate interface, we raise the possibility that some shallow slow slip events in the Nankai accretionary prism could originate from shearing in altered basalt.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Article number228275
JournalTectonophysics
Volume774
DOIs
StatePublished - Jan 5 2020

Fingerprint

basement rock
troughs
basements
Japan
trough
slip
subduction
rocks
friction
basalt
slip rate
shearing
convergent margin
fault slip
accretionary prism
plate boundary
thin section
expeditions
smectite
creep

All Science Journal Classification (ASJC) codes

  • Geophysics
  • Earth-Surface Processes

Cite this

@article{04d04588f61840f2b276eba8d905fd68,
title = "Implications of basement rock alteration in the Nankai Trough, Japan for subduction megathrust slip behavior",
abstract = "The Nankai Trough is an exceptionally well-studied convergent margin known to host damaging megathrust earthquakes as well as various forms of slow fault slip. Outcrop studies of exhumed analogues for the modern subduction thrust, as well as seismic reflection images of the active subduction zone, suggest that the basaltic basement participates in plate-boundary shearing at depths of a few km and greater. We obtained altered basaltic upper basement from the modern Nankai Trough seaward of the trench, recovered by drilling on IODP Expedition 333. We performed laboratory friction experiments on bare surfaces and gouge powders of this material, in addition to and in combination with other materials for comparison. The altered basalt exhibits predominantly velocity-strengthening frictional behavior, indicating a tendency for stable slip. For bare surface experiments, few instances of velocity-weakening friction occur and are restricted to slip rates of <10− 6 m/s. Thin sections and XRD analyses of the starting material indicate that the velocity-strengthening behavior is likely associated with the presence of clay minerals, mostly Mg-smectite, which coat the rims of larger, stronger grains. Based our friction data, we suggest that in addition to creep the altered Nankai basalts may also allow the possibility of slow slip events for two reasons: (1) velocity-weakening friction may be expected at low slip rates, but velocity-strengthening at higher rates will damp any potential slip instabilities; and (2) based on a critical stiffness criterion for accelerating (stable) slip, SSEs are capable of nucleating in the altered Nankai basalt despite velocity-strengthening friction. In light of these observations, and given the depth at which altered basement appears to be incorporated along the plate interface, we raise the possibility that some shallow slow slip events in the Nankai accretionary prism could originate from shearing in altered basalt.",
author = "Ikari, {Matt J.} and Wilckens, {Frederike K.} and Saffer, {Demian M.}",
year = "2020",
month = "1",
day = "5",
doi = "10.1016/j.tecto.2019.228275",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "774",
journal = "Tectonophysics",
issn = "0040-1951",
publisher = "Elsevier",

}

Implications of basement rock alteration in the Nankai Trough, Japan for subduction megathrust slip behavior. / Ikari, Matt J.; Wilckens, Frederike K.; Saffer, Demian M.

In: Tectonophysics, Vol. 774, 228275, 05.01.2020.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - Implications of basement rock alteration in the Nankai Trough, Japan for subduction megathrust slip behavior

AU - Ikari, Matt J.

AU - Wilckens, Frederike K.

AU - Saffer, Demian M.

PY - 2020/1/5

Y1 - 2020/1/5

N2 - The Nankai Trough is an exceptionally well-studied convergent margin known to host damaging megathrust earthquakes as well as various forms of slow fault slip. Outcrop studies of exhumed analogues for the modern subduction thrust, as well as seismic reflection images of the active subduction zone, suggest that the basaltic basement participates in plate-boundary shearing at depths of a few km and greater. We obtained altered basaltic upper basement from the modern Nankai Trough seaward of the trench, recovered by drilling on IODP Expedition 333. We performed laboratory friction experiments on bare surfaces and gouge powders of this material, in addition to and in combination with other materials for comparison. The altered basalt exhibits predominantly velocity-strengthening frictional behavior, indicating a tendency for stable slip. For bare surface experiments, few instances of velocity-weakening friction occur and are restricted to slip rates of <10− 6 m/s. Thin sections and XRD analyses of the starting material indicate that the velocity-strengthening behavior is likely associated with the presence of clay minerals, mostly Mg-smectite, which coat the rims of larger, stronger grains. Based our friction data, we suggest that in addition to creep the altered Nankai basalts may also allow the possibility of slow slip events for two reasons: (1) velocity-weakening friction may be expected at low slip rates, but velocity-strengthening at higher rates will damp any potential slip instabilities; and (2) based on a critical stiffness criterion for accelerating (stable) slip, SSEs are capable of nucleating in the altered Nankai basalt despite velocity-strengthening friction. In light of these observations, and given the depth at which altered basement appears to be incorporated along the plate interface, we raise the possibility that some shallow slow slip events in the Nankai accretionary prism could originate from shearing in altered basalt.

AB - The Nankai Trough is an exceptionally well-studied convergent margin known to host damaging megathrust earthquakes as well as various forms of slow fault slip. Outcrop studies of exhumed analogues for the modern subduction thrust, as well as seismic reflection images of the active subduction zone, suggest that the basaltic basement participates in plate-boundary shearing at depths of a few km and greater. We obtained altered basaltic upper basement from the modern Nankai Trough seaward of the trench, recovered by drilling on IODP Expedition 333. We performed laboratory friction experiments on bare surfaces and gouge powders of this material, in addition to and in combination with other materials for comparison. The altered basalt exhibits predominantly velocity-strengthening frictional behavior, indicating a tendency for stable slip. For bare surface experiments, few instances of velocity-weakening friction occur and are restricted to slip rates of <10− 6 m/s. Thin sections and XRD analyses of the starting material indicate that the velocity-strengthening behavior is likely associated with the presence of clay minerals, mostly Mg-smectite, which coat the rims of larger, stronger grains. Based our friction data, we suggest that in addition to creep the altered Nankai basalts may also allow the possibility of slow slip events for two reasons: (1) velocity-weakening friction may be expected at low slip rates, but velocity-strengthening at higher rates will damp any potential slip instabilities; and (2) based on a critical stiffness criterion for accelerating (stable) slip, SSEs are capable of nucleating in the altered Nankai basalt despite velocity-strengthening friction. In light of these observations, and given the depth at which altered basement appears to be incorporated along the plate interface, we raise the possibility that some shallow slow slip events in the Nankai accretionary prism could originate from shearing in altered basalt.

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85075205707&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=85075205707&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1016/j.tecto.2019.228275

DO - 10.1016/j.tecto.2019.228275

M3 - Article

AN - SCOPUS:85075205707

VL - 774

JO - Tectonophysics

JF - Tectonophysics

SN - 0040-1951

M1 - 228275

ER -