Investigating mixture interactions of astringent stimuli using the isobole approach

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

4 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Astringents (alum, malic acid, tannic acid) representing 3 broad classes (multivalent salts, organic acids, and polyphenols) were characterized alone, and as 2- and 3-component mixtures using isoboles. In experiment 1, participants rated 7 attributes ("astringency," the sub-qualities "drying," "roughing," and "puckering," and the side tastes "bitterness," "sourness," and "sweetness") using direct scaling. Quality specific power functions were calculated for each stimulus. In experiment 2, the same participants characterized 2- and 3-component mixtures. Multiple factor analysis (MFA) and hierarchical clustering on attribute ratings across stimuli indicate "astringency" is highly related to "bitterness" as well as "puckering," and the subqualities "drying" and "roughing" are somewhat redundant. Moreover, power functions were used to calculate indices of interaction (I) for each attribute/mixture combination. For "astringency," there was evidence of antagonism, regardless of the type of mixture. Conversely, for subqualities, the pattern of interaction depended on the mixture type. Alum/tannic acid and tannic acid/malic acid mixtures showed evidence of synergy for "drying" and "roughing"; alum/malic acid mixtures showed evidence of antagonism for "drying," "roughing," and "puckering." Collectively, these data clarify some semantic ambiguity regarding astringency and its subqualities, as well as the nature of interactions of among different types of astringents. Present data are not inconsistent with the idea that astringency arises from multiple mechanisms, although it remains to be determined whether the synergy observed here might reflect simultaneous activation of these multiple mechanisms.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)601-610
Number of pages10
JournalChemical senses
Volume41
Issue number7
DOIs
StatePublished - Sep 1 2016

Fingerprint

Astringents
Tannins
Polyphenols
Semantics
Statistical Factor Analysis
Cluster Analysis
Salts
Acids
malic acid
aluminum sulfate

All Science Journal Classification (ASJC) codes

  • Physiology
  • Sensory Systems
  • Physiology (medical)
  • Behavioral Neuroscience

Cite this

@article{00a9622a3f3947f3a48c96ce625db1d4,
title = "Investigating mixture interactions of astringent stimuli using the isobole approach",
abstract = "Astringents (alum, malic acid, tannic acid) representing 3 broad classes (multivalent salts, organic acids, and polyphenols) were characterized alone, and as 2- and 3-component mixtures using isoboles. In experiment 1, participants rated 7 attributes ({"}astringency,{"} the sub-qualities {"}drying,{"} {"}roughing,{"} and {"}puckering,{"} and the side tastes {"}bitterness,{"} {"}sourness,{"} and {"}sweetness{"}) using direct scaling. Quality specific power functions were calculated for each stimulus. In experiment 2, the same participants characterized 2- and 3-component mixtures. Multiple factor analysis (MFA) and hierarchical clustering on attribute ratings across stimuli indicate {"}astringency{"} is highly related to {"}bitterness{"} as well as {"}puckering,{"} and the subqualities {"}drying{"} and {"}roughing{"} are somewhat redundant. Moreover, power functions were used to calculate indices of interaction (I) for each attribute/mixture combination. For {"}astringency,{"} there was evidence of antagonism, regardless of the type of mixture. Conversely, for subqualities, the pattern of interaction depended on the mixture type. Alum/tannic acid and tannic acid/malic acid mixtures showed evidence of synergy for {"}drying{"} and {"}roughing{"}; alum/malic acid mixtures showed evidence of antagonism for {"}drying,{"} {"}roughing,{"} and {"}puckering.{"} Collectively, these data clarify some semantic ambiguity regarding astringency and its subqualities, as well as the nature of interactions of among different types of astringents. Present data are not inconsistent with the idea that astringency arises from multiple mechanisms, although it remains to be determined whether the synergy observed here might reflect simultaneous activation of these multiple mechanisms.",
author = "Fleming, {Erin E.} and Ziegler, {Gregory R.} and Hayes, {John E.}",
year = "2016",
month = "9",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1093/chemse/bjw064",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "41",
pages = "601--610",
journal = "Chemical Senses",
issn = "0379-864X",
publisher = "Oxford University Press",
number = "7",

}

Investigating mixture interactions of astringent stimuli using the isobole approach. / Fleming, Erin E.; Ziegler, Gregory R.; Hayes, John E.

In: Chemical senses, Vol. 41, No. 7, 01.09.2016, p. 601-610.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - Investigating mixture interactions of astringent stimuli using the isobole approach

AU - Fleming, Erin E.

AU - Ziegler, Gregory R.

AU - Hayes, John E.

PY - 2016/9/1

Y1 - 2016/9/1

N2 - Astringents (alum, malic acid, tannic acid) representing 3 broad classes (multivalent salts, organic acids, and polyphenols) were characterized alone, and as 2- and 3-component mixtures using isoboles. In experiment 1, participants rated 7 attributes ("astringency," the sub-qualities "drying," "roughing," and "puckering," and the side tastes "bitterness," "sourness," and "sweetness") using direct scaling. Quality specific power functions were calculated for each stimulus. In experiment 2, the same participants characterized 2- and 3-component mixtures. Multiple factor analysis (MFA) and hierarchical clustering on attribute ratings across stimuli indicate "astringency" is highly related to "bitterness" as well as "puckering," and the subqualities "drying" and "roughing" are somewhat redundant. Moreover, power functions were used to calculate indices of interaction (I) for each attribute/mixture combination. For "astringency," there was evidence of antagonism, regardless of the type of mixture. Conversely, for subqualities, the pattern of interaction depended on the mixture type. Alum/tannic acid and tannic acid/malic acid mixtures showed evidence of synergy for "drying" and "roughing"; alum/malic acid mixtures showed evidence of antagonism for "drying," "roughing," and "puckering." Collectively, these data clarify some semantic ambiguity regarding astringency and its subqualities, as well as the nature of interactions of among different types of astringents. Present data are not inconsistent with the idea that astringency arises from multiple mechanisms, although it remains to be determined whether the synergy observed here might reflect simultaneous activation of these multiple mechanisms.

AB - Astringents (alum, malic acid, tannic acid) representing 3 broad classes (multivalent salts, organic acids, and polyphenols) were characterized alone, and as 2- and 3-component mixtures using isoboles. In experiment 1, participants rated 7 attributes ("astringency," the sub-qualities "drying," "roughing," and "puckering," and the side tastes "bitterness," "sourness," and "sweetness") using direct scaling. Quality specific power functions were calculated for each stimulus. In experiment 2, the same participants characterized 2- and 3-component mixtures. Multiple factor analysis (MFA) and hierarchical clustering on attribute ratings across stimuli indicate "astringency" is highly related to "bitterness" as well as "puckering," and the subqualities "drying" and "roughing" are somewhat redundant. Moreover, power functions were used to calculate indices of interaction (I) for each attribute/mixture combination. For "astringency," there was evidence of antagonism, regardless of the type of mixture. Conversely, for subqualities, the pattern of interaction depended on the mixture type. Alum/tannic acid and tannic acid/malic acid mixtures showed evidence of synergy for "drying" and "roughing"; alum/malic acid mixtures showed evidence of antagonism for "drying," "roughing," and "puckering." Collectively, these data clarify some semantic ambiguity regarding astringency and its subqualities, as well as the nature of interactions of among different types of astringents. Present data are not inconsistent with the idea that astringency arises from multiple mechanisms, although it remains to be determined whether the synergy observed here might reflect simultaneous activation of these multiple mechanisms.

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84985029827&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=84985029827&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1093/chemse/bjw064

DO - 10.1093/chemse/bjw064

M3 - Article

C2 - 27252355

AN - SCOPUS:84985029827

VL - 41

SP - 601

EP - 610

JO - Chemical Senses

JF - Chemical Senses

SN - 0379-864X

IS - 7

ER -