Low-disturbance manure incorporation effects on ammonia and nitrate loss

Curtis James Dell, Peter J A Kleinman, John P. Schmidt, Douglas Brian Beegle

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

35 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Low-disturbance manure application methods can provide the benefits of manure incorporation, including reducing ammonia (NH3) emissions, in production systems where tillage is not possible. However, incorporation can exacerbate nitrate (NO3 -) leaching. We sought to assess the trade-off s in NH3 and NO3 - losses caused by alternative manure application methods. Dairy slurry (2006-2007) and liquid swine manure (2008-2009) were applied to no-till corn by (i) shallow (<10 cm) disk injection, (ii) surface banding with soil aeration, (iii) broadcasting, and (iv) broadcasting with tillage incorporation. Ammonia emissions were monitored for 72 h aft er application using ventilated chambers and passive diff usion samplers, and NO3 - leaching to 80 cm was monitored with buried column lysimeters. The greatest NH3 emissions occurred with broadcasting (35-63 kg NH3-N ha-1), and the lowest emissions were from unamended soil (<1 kg NH3-N ha-1). Injection decreased NH3-N emissions by 91 to 99% compared with broadcasting and resulted in lower emissions than tillage incorporation 1 h aft er broadcasting. Ammonia-nitrogen emissions from banding manure with aeration were inconsistent between years, averaging 0 to 71% that of broadcasting. Annual NO3 - leaching losses were small (<25 kg NO3 -N ha-1) and similar between treatments, except for the first winter when NO3 - leaching was fivefold greater with injection. Because NO3 - leaching with injection was substantially lower over subsequent seasons, we hypothesize that the elevated losses during the first winter were through preferential flow paths inadvertently created during lysimeter installation. Overall, shallow disk injection yielded the lowest NH3 emissions without consistently increasing NO3 - leaching, whereas manure banding with soil aeration conserved inconsistent amounts of N.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)928-937
Number of pages10
JournalJournal of Environmental Quality
Volume41
Issue number3
DOIs
StatePublished - May 1 2012

Fingerprint

Manures
Broadcasting
Leaching
manure
Ammonia
Nitrates
ammonia
nitrate
disturbance
leaching
Lysimeters
aeration
tillage
Soils
lysimeter
Dairies
soil
incorporation
loss
effect

All Science Journal Classification (ASJC) codes

  • Environmental Engineering
  • Water Science and Technology
  • Waste Management and Disposal
  • Pollution
  • Management, Monitoring, Policy and Law

Cite this

Dell, Curtis James ; Kleinman, Peter J A ; Schmidt, John P. ; Beegle, Douglas Brian. / Low-disturbance manure incorporation effects on ammonia and nitrate loss. In: Journal of Environmental Quality. 2012 ; Vol. 41, No. 3. pp. 928-937.
@article{9c50fb923b7049c5bb3e81444ce139a7,
title = "Low-disturbance manure incorporation effects on ammonia and nitrate loss",
abstract = "Low-disturbance manure application methods can provide the benefits of manure incorporation, including reducing ammonia (NH3) emissions, in production systems where tillage is not possible. However, incorporation can exacerbate nitrate (NO3 -) leaching. We sought to assess the trade-off s in NH3 and NO3 - losses caused by alternative manure application methods. Dairy slurry (2006-2007) and liquid swine manure (2008-2009) were applied to no-till corn by (i) shallow (<10 cm) disk injection, (ii) surface banding with soil aeration, (iii) broadcasting, and (iv) broadcasting with tillage incorporation. Ammonia emissions were monitored for 72 h aft er application using ventilated chambers and passive diff usion samplers, and NO3 - leaching to 80 cm was monitored with buried column lysimeters. The greatest NH3 emissions occurred with broadcasting (35-63 kg NH3-N ha-1), and the lowest emissions were from unamended soil (<1 kg NH3-N ha-1). Injection decreased NH3-N emissions by 91 to 99{\%} compared with broadcasting and resulted in lower emissions than tillage incorporation 1 h aft er broadcasting. Ammonia-nitrogen emissions from banding manure with aeration were inconsistent between years, averaging 0 to 71{\%} that of broadcasting. Annual NO3 - leaching losses were small (<25 kg NO3 -N ha-1) and similar between treatments, except for the first winter when NO3 - leaching was fivefold greater with injection. Because NO3 - leaching with injection was substantially lower over subsequent seasons, we hypothesize that the elevated losses during the first winter were through preferential flow paths inadvertently created during lysimeter installation. Overall, shallow disk injection yielded the lowest NH3 emissions without consistently increasing NO3 - leaching, whereas manure banding with soil aeration conserved inconsistent amounts of N.",
author = "Dell, {Curtis James} and Kleinman, {Peter J A} and Schmidt, {John P.} and Beegle, {Douglas Brian}",
year = "2012",
month = "5",
day = "1",
doi = "10.2134/jeq2011.0327",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "41",
pages = "928--937",
journal = "Journal of Environmental Quality",
issn = "0047-2425",
publisher = "ASA/CSSA/SSSA",
number = "3",

}

Low-disturbance manure incorporation effects on ammonia and nitrate loss. / Dell, Curtis James; Kleinman, Peter J A; Schmidt, John P.; Beegle, Douglas Brian.

In: Journal of Environmental Quality, Vol. 41, No. 3, 01.05.2012, p. 928-937.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - Low-disturbance manure incorporation effects on ammonia and nitrate loss

AU - Dell, Curtis James

AU - Kleinman, Peter J A

AU - Schmidt, John P.

AU - Beegle, Douglas Brian

PY - 2012/5/1

Y1 - 2012/5/1

N2 - Low-disturbance manure application methods can provide the benefits of manure incorporation, including reducing ammonia (NH3) emissions, in production systems where tillage is not possible. However, incorporation can exacerbate nitrate (NO3 -) leaching. We sought to assess the trade-off s in NH3 and NO3 - losses caused by alternative manure application methods. Dairy slurry (2006-2007) and liquid swine manure (2008-2009) were applied to no-till corn by (i) shallow (<10 cm) disk injection, (ii) surface banding with soil aeration, (iii) broadcasting, and (iv) broadcasting with tillage incorporation. Ammonia emissions were monitored for 72 h aft er application using ventilated chambers and passive diff usion samplers, and NO3 - leaching to 80 cm was monitored with buried column lysimeters. The greatest NH3 emissions occurred with broadcasting (35-63 kg NH3-N ha-1), and the lowest emissions were from unamended soil (<1 kg NH3-N ha-1). Injection decreased NH3-N emissions by 91 to 99% compared with broadcasting and resulted in lower emissions than tillage incorporation 1 h aft er broadcasting. Ammonia-nitrogen emissions from banding manure with aeration were inconsistent between years, averaging 0 to 71% that of broadcasting. Annual NO3 - leaching losses were small (<25 kg NO3 -N ha-1) and similar between treatments, except for the first winter when NO3 - leaching was fivefold greater with injection. Because NO3 - leaching with injection was substantially lower over subsequent seasons, we hypothesize that the elevated losses during the first winter were through preferential flow paths inadvertently created during lysimeter installation. Overall, shallow disk injection yielded the lowest NH3 emissions without consistently increasing NO3 - leaching, whereas manure banding with soil aeration conserved inconsistent amounts of N.

AB - Low-disturbance manure application methods can provide the benefits of manure incorporation, including reducing ammonia (NH3) emissions, in production systems where tillage is not possible. However, incorporation can exacerbate nitrate (NO3 -) leaching. We sought to assess the trade-off s in NH3 and NO3 - losses caused by alternative manure application methods. Dairy slurry (2006-2007) and liquid swine manure (2008-2009) were applied to no-till corn by (i) shallow (<10 cm) disk injection, (ii) surface banding with soil aeration, (iii) broadcasting, and (iv) broadcasting with tillage incorporation. Ammonia emissions were monitored for 72 h aft er application using ventilated chambers and passive diff usion samplers, and NO3 - leaching to 80 cm was monitored with buried column lysimeters. The greatest NH3 emissions occurred with broadcasting (35-63 kg NH3-N ha-1), and the lowest emissions were from unamended soil (<1 kg NH3-N ha-1). Injection decreased NH3-N emissions by 91 to 99% compared with broadcasting and resulted in lower emissions than tillage incorporation 1 h aft er broadcasting. Ammonia-nitrogen emissions from banding manure with aeration were inconsistent between years, averaging 0 to 71% that of broadcasting. Annual NO3 - leaching losses were small (<25 kg NO3 -N ha-1) and similar between treatments, except for the first winter when NO3 - leaching was fivefold greater with injection. Because NO3 - leaching with injection was substantially lower over subsequent seasons, we hypothesize that the elevated losses during the first winter were through preferential flow paths inadvertently created during lysimeter installation. Overall, shallow disk injection yielded the lowest NH3 emissions without consistently increasing NO3 - leaching, whereas manure banding with soil aeration conserved inconsistent amounts of N.

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84862263854&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=84862263854&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.2134/jeq2011.0327

DO - 10.2134/jeq2011.0327

M3 - Article

VL - 41

SP - 928

EP - 937

JO - Journal of Environmental Quality

JF - Journal of Environmental Quality

SN - 0047-2425

IS - 3

ER -