Manual Stress Ankle Radiography Has Poor Ability to Predict Deep Deltoid Ligament Integrity in a Supination External Rotation Fracture Cohort

Patrick C. Schottel, Peter D. Fabricant, Marschall B. Berkes, Matthew Garner, Milton T.M. Little, Keith D. Hentel, Douglas N. Mintz, David L. Helfet, Dean G. Lorich

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

11 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Stress ankle radiographs are routinely performed to determine deep deltoid ligament integrity in supination external rotation (SER) ankle fractures. However, variability is present in the published data regarding what medial clear space (MCS) value constitutes a positive result. The purposes of the present study were to evaluate the diagnostic accuracy of different MCS cutoff values and determine whether this clinical test could accurately discriminate between patients with and without a deep deltoid ligament disruption. MCS measurements were recorded for stress ankle injury radiographs in an SER ankle fracture cohort. Preoperative ankle magnetic resonance imaging studies, obtained for all patients, were then read independently by 2 musculoskeletal attending radiologists to determine deep deltoid ligament integrity. The MCS measurements were compared with the magnetic resonance imaging diagnosis using receiver operating characteristic analyses to determine the sensitivity, specificity, and optimal data-driven cutoff values. SER II-III patients demonstrated a mean stress MCS distance of 4.3 ± 0.98 mm compared with 5.8 ± 1.76 mm in the SER IV cohort (p <.001). An analysis of differing MCS positive cutoff thresholds revealed that a stress MCS of 5.0 mm maximized the combined sensitivity and specificity of the external rotation test: 65.8% sensitive and 76.5% specific. Using the receiver operating characteristic curve analysis of the MCS measurement, the calculated area under the curve was 0.77, indicating inadequate discriminative ability for diagnosing SER pattern fractures with or without a deep deltoid ligament tear. Judicious use of additional diagnostic testing in patients with a stress MCS result between 4.0 mm and 5.5 mm is warranted.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)531-535
Number of pages5
JournalJournal of Foot and Ankle Surgery
Volume54
Issue number4
DOIs
StatePublished - Jul 1 2015

Fingerprint

Supination
Ligaments
Ankle
Radiography
Ankle Fractures
ROC Curve
Magnetic Resonance Imaging
Ankle Injuries
Sensitivity and Specificity
Area Under Curve

All Science Journal Classification (ASJC) codes

  • Surgery
  • Orthopedics and Sports Medicine

Cite this

Schottel, Patrick C. ; Fabricant, Peter D. ; Berkes, Marschall B. ; Garner, Matthew ; Little, Milton T.M. ; Hentel, Keith D. ; Mintz, Douglas N. ; Helfet, David L. ; Lorich, Dean G. / Manual Stress Ankle Radiography Has Poor Ability to Predict Deep Deltoid Ligament Integrity in a Supination External Rotation Fracture Cohort. In: Journal of Foot and Ankle Surgery. 2015 ; Vol. 54, No. 4. pp. 531-535.
@article{e525ac5f647e49fea45ca05c79a90ab7,
title = "Manual Stress Ankle Radiography Has Poor Ability to Predict Deep Deltoid Ligament Integrity in a Supination External Rotation Fracture Cohort",
abstract = "Stress ankle radiographs are routinely performed to determine deep deltoid ligament integrity in supination external rotation (SER) ankle fractures. However, variability is present in the published data regarding what medial clear space (MCS) value constitutes a positive result. The purposes of the present study were to evaluate the diagnostic accuracy of different MCS cutoff values and determine whether this clinical test could accurately discriminate between patients with and without a deep deltoid ligament disruption. MCS measurements were recorded for stress ankle injury radiographs in an SER ankle fracture cohort. Preoperative ankle magnetic resonance imaging studies, obtained for all patients, were then read independently by 2 musculoskeletal attending radiologists to determine deep deltoid ligament integrity. The MCS measurements were compared with the magnetic resonance imaging diagnosis using receiver operating characteristic analyses to determine the sensitivity, specificity, and optimal data-driven cutoff values. SER II-III patients demonstrated a mean stress MCS distance of 4.3 ± 0.98 mm compared with 5.8 ± 1.76 mm in the SER IV cohort (p <.001). An analysis of differing MCS positive cutoff thresholds revealed that a stress MCS of 5.0 mm maximized the combined sensitivity and specificity of the external rotation test: 65.8{\%} sensitive and 76.5{\%} specific. Using the receiver operating characteristic curve analysis of the MCS measurement, the calculated area under the curve was 0.77, indicating inadequate discriminative ability for diagnosing SER pattern fractures with or without a deep deltoid ligament tear. Judicious use of additional diagnostic testing in patients with a stress MCS result between 4.0 mm and 5.5 mm is warranted.",
author = "Schottel, {Patrick C.} and Fabricant, {Peter D.} and Berkes, {Marschall B.} and Matthew Garner and Little, {Milton T.M.} and Hentel, {Keith D.} and Mintz, {Douglas N.} and Helfet, {David L.} and Lorich, {Dean G.}",
year = "2015",
month = "7",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1053/j.jfas.2014.07.007",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "54",
pages = "531--535",
journal = "Journal of Foot and Ankle Surgery",
issn = "1067-2516",
publisher = "Academic Press Inc.",
number = "4",

}

Manual Stress Ankle Radiography Has Poor Ability to Predict Deep Deltoid Ligament Integrity in a Supination External Rotation Fracture Cohort. / Schottel, Patrick C.; Fabricant, Peter D.; Berkes, Marschall B.; Garner, Matthew; Little, Milton T.M.; Hentel, Keith D.; Mintz, Douglas N.; Helfet, David L.; Lorich, Dean G.

In: Journal of Foot and Ankle Surgery, Vol. 54, No. 4, 01.07.2015, p. 531-535.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - Manual Stress Ankle Radiography Has Poor Ability to Predict Deep Deltoid Ligament Integrity in a Supination External Rotation Fracture Cohort

AU - Schottel, Patrick C.

AU - Fabricant, Peter D.

AU - Berkes, Marschall B.

AU - Garner, Matthew

AU - Little, Milton T.M.

AU - Hentel, Keith D.

AU - Mintz, Douglas N.

AU - Helfet, David L.

AU - Lorich, Dean G.

PY - 2015/7/1

Y1 - 2015/7/1

N2 - Stress ankle radiographs are routinely performed to determine deep deltoid ligament integrity in supination external rotation (SER) ankle fractures. However, variability is present in the published data regarding what medial clear space (MCS) value constitutes a positive result. The purposes of the present study were to evaluate the diagnostic accuracy of different MCS cutoff values and determine whether this clinical test could accurately discriminate between patients with and without a deep deltoid ligament disruption. MCS measurements were recorded for stress ankle injury radiographs in an SER ankle fracture cohort. Preoperative ankle magnetic resonance imaging studies, obtained for all patients, were then read independently by 2 musculoskeletal attending radiologists to determine deep deltoid ligament integrity. The MCS measurements were compared with the magnetic resonance imaging diagnosis using receiver operating characteristic analyses to determine the sensitivity, specificity, and optimal data-driven cutoff values. SER II-III patients demonstrated a mean stress MCS distance of 4.3 ± 0.98 mm compared with 5.8 ± 1.76 mm in the SER IV cohort (p <.001). An analysis of differing MCS positive cutoff thresholds revealed that a stress MCS of 5.0 mm maximized the combined sensitivity and specificity of the external rotation test: 65.8% sensitive and 76.5% specific. Using the receiver operating characteristic curve analysis of the MCS measurement, the calculated area under the curve was 0.77, indicating inadequate discriminative ability for diagnosing SER pattern fractures with or without a deep deltoid ligament tear. Judicious use of additional diagnostic testing in patients with a stress MCS result between 4.0 mm and 5.5 mm is warranted.

AB - Stress ankle radiographs are routinely performed to determine deep deltoid ligament integrity in supination external rotation (SER) ankle fractures. However, variability is present in the published data regarding what medial clear space (MCS) value constitutes a positive result. The purposes of the present study were to evaluate the diagnostic accuracy of different MCS cutoff values and determine whether this clinical test could accurately discriminate between patients with and without a deep deltoid ligament disruption. MCS measurements were recorded for stress ankle injury radiographs in an SER ankle fracture cohort. Preoperative ankle magnetic resonance imaging studies, obtained for all patients, were then read independently by 2 musculoskeletal attending radiologists to determine deep deltoid ligament integrity. The MCS measurements were compared with the magnetic resonance imaging diagnosis using receiver operating characteristic analyses to determine the sensitivity, specificity, and optimal data-driven cutoff values. SER II-III patients demonstrated a mean stress MCS distance of 4.3 ± 0.98 mm compared with 5.8 ± 1.76 mm in the SER IV cohort (p <.001). An analysis of differing MCS positive cutoff thresholds revealed that a stress MCS of 5.0 mm maximized the combined sensitivity and specificity of the external rotation test: 65.8% sensitive and 76.5% specific. Using the receiver operating characteristic curve analysis of the MCS measurement, the calculated area under the curve was 0.77, indicating inadequate discriminative ability for diagnosing SER pattern fractures with or without a deep deltoid ligament tear. Judicious use of additional diagnostic testing in patients with a stress MCS result between 4.0 mm and 5.5 mm is warranted.

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84937555183&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=84937555183&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1053/j.jfas.2014.07.007

DO - 10.1053/j.jfas.2014.07.007

M3 - Article

C2 - 25189335

AN - SCOPUS:84937555183

VL - 54

SP - 531

EP - 535

JO - Journal of Foot and Ankle Surgery

JF - Journal of Foot and Ankle Surgery

SN - 1067-2516

IS - 4

ER -