One shape fits all, but only in the aggregate: Diversity in sub-stand scale diameter distributions

Eric K. Zenner, Jeri Lynn E. Peck, Khosro Sagheb-Talebi

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

3 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Questions: To what extent are the sub-stand size class distributions at the neighbourhood patch scale masked at the stand level via spatial smoothing? What are the implications for naturalness assessment of obscuring, at the stand level, structures that arise from endogenous processes at the neighbourhood scale?. Location: Elborz Mountains, south of the Caspian Sea, Iran. Methods: Natural uneven-aged old-growth Oriental beech (Fagus orientalis) forest subject to fine-scale disturbances was stem-mapped in a 1.2-ha plot of live trees >7.5 cm DBH; neighbourhoods were delineated across multiple scales using the tree-centred floating neighbourhood approach of spatial tessellation to connect trees to their natural neighbours. Cluster analysis was used to identify an optimal number of recurring diameter distribution types (DDT) based on the proportion of trees in each of the five size classes. The richness of DDTs was assessed and the extent of DDTs was modelled as a function of tree size. Results: The number of member trees and spatial extent increased with neighbourhood scale. While the stand-level tree size class distribution exhibited a rotated sigmoid shape, the nine most distinct DDTs were characterized by four different distribution shapes (negative exponential, increasing-q, rotated sigmoid and unimodal) and varied considerably in the abundance of trees in different size classes. Each individual tree contributed to at least three of the nine DDTs, which were nonetheless spatially distinct and varied in extent with size class composition. As expected, all metrics exhibited spatial smoothing (i.e., increasing homogeneity with increasing scale) as small, heterogeneous tree neighbourhoods were expanded into larger neighbourhoods with more similar average composition, which converged on a rotated sigmoid shape at the broadest scale. Conclusions: The stand-level rotated sigmoid distribution reflected spatial smoothing across more heterogeneous fine-scale tree neighbourhood patches. Further studies are needed to assess if a better measure of natural forest structure may be the diversity of sub-stand structures and the contribution of individual trees to that diversity, rather than an aggregated metric that averages across the hallmark heterogeneity of neighbourhood dynamics.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)501-510
Number of pages10
JournalJournal of Vegetation Science
Volume29
Issue number3
DOIs
StatePublished - May 2018

Fingerprint

DDT
tree classes
smoothing
distribution
Fagus sylvatica subsp. orientalis
Caspian Sea
stand structure
naturalness
Fagus
Iran
cluster analysis
homogeneity
mountains
spatial distribution
stem
stems
disturbance
mountain
methodology

All Science Journal Classification (ASJC) codes

  • Ecology
  • Plant Science

Cite this

@article{fdfe0aa491864d5987aa8883d8577237,
title = "One shape fits all, but only in the aggregate: Diversity in sub-stand scale diameter distributions",
abstract = "Questions: To what extent are the sub-stand size class distributions at the neighbourhood patch scale masked at the stand level via spatial smoothing? What are the implications for naturalness assessment of obscuring, at the stand level, structures that arise from endogenous processes at the neighbourhood scale?. Location: Elborz Mountains, south of the Caspian Sea, Iran. Methods: Natural uneven-aged old-growth Oriental beech (Fagus orientalis) forest subject to fine-scale disturbances was stem-mapped in a 1.2-ha plot of live trees >7.5 cm DBH; neighbourhoods were delineated across multiple scales using the tree-centred floating neighbourhood approach of spatial tessellation to connect trees to their natural neighbours. Cluster analysis was used to identify an optimal number of recurring diameter distribution types (DDT) based on the proportion of trees in each of the five size classes. The richness of DDTs was assessed and the extent of DDTs was modelled as a function of tree size. Results: The number of member trees and spatial extent increased with neighbourhood scale. While the stand-level tree size class distribution exhibited a rotated sigmoid shape, the nine most distinct DDTs were characterized by four different distribution shapes (negative exponential, increasing-q, rotated sigmoid and unimodal) and varied considerably in the abundance of trees in different size classes. Each individual tree contributed to at least three of the nine DDTs, which were nonetheless spatially distinct and varied in extent with size class composition. As expected, all metrics exhibited spatial smoothing (i.e., increasing homogeneity with increasing scale) as small, heterogeneous tree neighbourhoods were expanded into larger neighbourhoods with more similar average composition, which converged on a rotated sigmoid shape at the broadest scale. Conclusions: The stand-level rotated sigmoid distribution reflected spatial smoothing across more heterogeneous fine-scale tree neighbourhood patches. Further studies are needed to assess if a better measure of natural forest structure may be the diversity of sub-stand structures and the contribution of individual trees to that diversity, rather than an aggregated metric that averages across the hallmark heterogeneity of neighbourhood dynamics.",
author = "Zenner, {Eric K.} and Peck, {Jeri Lynn E.} and Khosro Sagheb-Talebi",
year = "2018",
month = "5",
doi = "10.1111/jvs.12634",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "29",
pages = "501--510",
journal = "Journal of Vegetation Science",
issn = "1100-9233",
publisher = "Wiley-Blackwell",
number = "3",

}

One shape fits all, but only in the aggregate : Diversity in sub-stand scale diameter distributions. / Zenner, Eric K.; Peck, Jeri Lynn E.; Sagheb-Talebi, Khosro.

In: Journal of Vegetation Science, Vol. 29, No. 3, 05.2018, p. 501-510.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - One shape fits all, but only in the aggregate

T2 - Diversity in sub-stand scale diameter distributions

AU - Zenner, Eric K.

AU - Peck, Jeri Lynn E.

AU - Sagheb-Talebi, Khosro

PY - 2018/5

Y1 - 2018/5

N2 - Questions: To what extent are the sub-stand size class distributions at the neighbourhood patch scale masked at the stand level via spatial smoothing? What are the implications for naturalness assessment of obscuring, at the stand level, structures that arise from endogenous processes at the neighbourhood scale?. Location: Elborz Mountains, south of the Caspian Sea, Iran. Methods: Natural uneven-aged old-growth Oriental beech (Fagus orientalis) forest subject to fine-scale disturbances was stem-mapped in a 1.2-ha plot of live trees >7.5 cm DBH; neighbourhoods were delineated across multiple scales using the tree-centred floating neighbourhood approach of spatial tessellation to connect trees to their natural neighbours. Cluster analysis was used to identify an optimal number of recurring diameter distribution types (DDT) based on the proportion of trees in each of the five size classes. The richness of DDTs was assessed and the extent of DDTs was modelled as a function of tree size. Results: The number of member trees and spatial extent increased with neighbourhood scale. While the stand-level tree size class distribution exhibited a rotated sigmoid shape, the nine most distinct DDTs were characterized by four different distribution shapes (negative exponential, increasing-q, rotated sigmoid and unimodal) and varied considerably in the abundance of trees in different size classes. Each individual tree contributed to at least three of the nine DDTs, which were nonetheless spatially distinct and varied in extent with size class composition. As expected, all metrics exhibited spatial smoothing (i.e., increasing homogeneity with increasing scale) as small, heterogeneous tree neighbourhoods were expanded into larger neighbourhoods with more similar average composition, which converged on a rotated sigmoid shape at the broadest scale. Conclusions: The stand-level rotated sigmoid distribution reflected spatial smoothing across more heterogeneous fine-scale tree neighbourhood patches. Further studies are needed to assess if a better measure of natural forest structure may be the diversity of sub-stand structures and the contribution of individual trees to that diversity, rather than an aggregated metric that averages across the hallmark heterogeneity of neighbourhood dynamics.

AB - Questions: To what extent are the sub-stand size class distributions at the neighbourhood patch scale masked at the stand level via spatial smoothing? What are the implications for naturalness assessment of obscuring, at the stand level, structures that arise from endogenous processes at the neighbourhood scale?. Location: Elborz Mountains, south of the Caspian Sea, Iran. Methods: Natural uneven-aged old-growth Oriental beech (Fagus orientalis) forest subject to fine-scale disturbances was stem-mapped in a 1.2-ha plot of live trees >7.5 cm DBH; neighbourhoods were delineated across multiple scales using the tree-centred floating neighbourhood approach of spatial tessellation to connect trees to their natural neighbours. Cluster analysis was used to identify an optimal number of recurring diameter distribution types (DDT) based on the proportion of trees in each of the five size classes. The richness of DDTs was assessed and the extent of DDTs was modelled as a function of tree size. Results: The number of member trees and spatial extent increased with neighbourhood scale. While the stand-level tree size class distribution exhibited a rotated sigmoid shape, the nine most distinct DDTs were characterized by four different distribution shapes (negative exponential, increasing-q, rotated sigmoid and unimodal) and varied considerably in the abundance of trees in different size classes. Each individual tree contributed to at least three of the nine DDTs, which were nonetheless spatially distinct and varied in extent with size class composition. As expected, all metrics exhibited spatial smoothing (i.e., increasing homogeneity with increasing scale) as small, heterogeneous tree neighbourhoods were expanded into larger neighbourhoods with more similar average composition, which converged on a rotated sigmoid shape at the broadest scale. Conclusions: The stand-level rotated sigmoid distribution reflected spatial smoothing across more heterogeneous fine-scale tree neighbourhood patches. Further studies are needed to assess if a better measure of natural forest structure may be the diversity of sub-stand structures and the contribution of individual trees to that diversity, rather than an aggregated metric that averages across the hallmark heterogeneity of neighbourhood dynamics.

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85047411391&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=85047411391&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1111/jvs.12634

DO - 10.1111/jvs.12634

M3 - Article

AN - SCOPUS:85047411391

VL - 29

SP - 501

EP - 510

JO - Journal of Vegetation Science

JF - Journal of Vegetation Science

SN - 1100-9233

IS - 3

ER -