Performance of 'Golden Delicious', 'Jonagold', 'Empire', and 'Rome Beauty' apple trees on five rootstocks over ten years in the 1990 NC-140 Cultivar/Rootstock Trial

W. R. Autio, J. L. Anderson, J. A. Barden, G. R. Brown, Robert Michael Crassweller, P. A. Domoto, A. Erb, D. C. Ferree, A. Gaus, P. M. Hirst, C. A. Mullins, James Rawlinson Schupp

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

13 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

At 12 sites in the United States, trials were established in 1990 which included four apple (Malus X domestica Borkh.) cultivars ('Smoothee Golden Delicious', 'Nicobel Jonagold', 'Empire', and 'Law Rome Beauty') in all combinations on five rootstocks (M.9 EMLA, B.9, Mark, O.3, and M.26 EMLA). After ten growing seasons, rootstock and scion cultivar interacted significantly to affect trunk cross-sectional area (TCA), root suckering, yield efficiency, and fruit size but not survival or yield per tree. In all cases these statistically significant interactions contributed minimally to the variability among rootstocks and were relatively unimportant in determining tree performance. Comparing cultivars after 10 years, survival was greatest for 'Empire' and poorest for 'Rome'. 'Jonagold' had the largest TCA, and 'Empire' and 'Rome' had the smallest. Root suckering occurred most prevalently with 'Empire'. 'Rome' yielded the most, and 'Jonagold' and 'Empire' yielded the least. 'Rome' trees also were the most yield efficient, and 'Jonagold' trees were the least efficient. Largest fruit were 'Rome' and 'Jonagold'. Comparing rootstock effects over 10 years, B.9 resulted in the greater tree survival than did O.3. M.9 EMLA, and Mark, and M.26 EMLA resulted in intermediate survival. Trees with the greatest TCA were on M.26 EMLA. Trees on M.9 EMLA and those on O.3 were similar and significantly smaller. Trees on B.9 and those on Mark were similar in size and the smallest in the trial. The greatest root suckering developed from B.9, Mark, and O.3, and the least came from M.26 EMLA. Trees on M.26 EMLA, O.3, and M.9 EMLA yielded similarly and significantly more than those on B.9 or Mark. The most yield efficient trees, however, were on B.9 and Mark, and the least were on M.26 EMLA. M.26 EMLA and M.9 EMLA resulted in the largest fruit size, and Mark resulted in the smallest.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)131-137
Number of pages7
JournalJournal of the American Pomological Society
Volume55
Issue number3
StatePublished - Jul 1 2001

Fingerprint

rootstocks
apples
cultivars
suckering
tree trunk
fruits
Malus
scions
growing season

All Science Journal Classification (ASJC) codes

  • Horticulture

Cite this

Autio, W. R. ; Anderson, J. L. ; Barden, J. A. ; Brown, G. R. ; Crassweller, Robert Michael ; Domoto, P. A. ; Erb, A. ; Ferree, D. C. ; Gaus, A. ; Hirst, P. M. ; Mullins, C. A. ; Schupp, James Rawlinson. / Performance of 'Golden Delicious', 'Jonagold', 'Empire', and 'Rome Beauty' apple trees on five rootstocks over ten years in the 1990 NC-140 Cultivar/Rootstock Trial. In: Journal of the American Pomological Society. 2001 ; Vol. 55, No. 3. pp. 131-137.
@article{8b48194b795b42159c16032a55accf79,
title = "Performance of 'Golden Delicious', 'Jonagold', 'Empire', and 'Rome Beauty' apple trees on five rootstocks over ten years in the 1990 NC-140 Cultivar/Rootstock Trial",
abstract = "At 12 sites in the United States, trials were established in 1990 which included four apple (Malus X domestica Borkh.) cultivars ('Smoothee Golden Delicious', 'Nicobel Jonagold', 'Empire', and 'Law Rome Beauty') in all combinations on five rootstocks (M.9 EMLA, B.9, Mark, O.3, and M.26 EMLA). After ten growing seasons, rootstock and scion cultivar interacted significantly to affect trunk cross-sectional area (TCA), root suckering, yield efficiency, and fruit size but not survival or yield per tree. In all cases these statistically significant interactions contributed minimally to the variability among rootstocks and were relatively unimportant in determining tree performance. Comparing cultivars after 10 years, survival was greatest for 'Empire' and poorest for 'Rome'. 'Jonagold' had the largest TCA, and 'Empire' and 'Rome' had the smallest. Root suckering occurred most prevalently with 'Empire'. 'Rome' yielded the most, and 'Jonagold' and 'Empire' yielded the least. 'Rome' trees also were the most yield efficient, and 'Jonagold' trees were the least efficient. Largest fruit were 'Rome' and 'Jonagold'. Comparing rootstock effects over 10 years, B.9 resulted in the greater tree survival than did O.3. M.9 EMLA, and Mark, and M.26 EMLA resulted in intermediate survival. Trees with the greatest TCA were on M.26 EMLA. Trees on M.9 EMLA and those on O.3 were similar and significantly smaller. Trees on B.9 and those on Mark were similar in size and the smallest in the trial. The greatest root suckering developed from B.9, Mark, and O.3, and the least came from M.26 EMLA. Trees on M.26 EMLA, O.3, and M.9 EMLA yielded similarly and significantly more than those on B.9 or Mark. The most yield efficient trees, however, were on B.9 and Mark, and the least were on M.26 EMLA. M.26 EMLA and M.9 EMLA resulted in the largest fruit size, and Mark resulted in the smallest.",
author = "Autio, {W. R.} and Anderson, {J. L.} and Barden, {J. A.} and Brown, {G. R.} and Crassweller, {Robert Michael} and Domoto, {P. A.} and A. Erb and Ferree, {D. C.} and A. Gaus and Hirst, {P. M.} and Mullins, {C. A.} and Schupp, {James Rawlinson}",
year = "2001",
month = "7",
day = "1",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "55",
pages = "131--137",
journal = "Journal of the American Pomological Society",
issn = "1527-3741",
publisher = "American Pomological Society",
number = "3",

}

Performance of 'Golden Delicious', 'Jonagold', 'Empire', and 'Rome Beauty' apple trees on five rootstocks over ten years in the 1990 NC-140 Cultivar/Rootstock Trial. / Autio, W. R.; Anderson, J. L.; Barden, J. A.; Brown, G. R.; Crassweller, Robert Michael; Domoto, P. A.; Erb, A.; Ferree, D. C.; Gaus, A.; Hirst, P. M.; Mullins, C. A.; Schupp, James Rawlinson.

In: Journal of the American Pomological Society, Vol. 55, No. 3, 01.07.2001, p. 131-137.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - Performance of 'Golden Delicious', 'Jonagold', 'Empire', and 'Rome Beauty' apple trees on five rootstocks over ten years in the 1990 NC-140 Cultivar/Rootstock Trial

AU - Autio, W. R.

AU - Anderson, J. L.

AU - Barden, J. A.

AU - Brown, G. R.

AU - Crassweller, Robert Michael

AU - Domoto, P. A.

AU - Erb, A.

AU - Ferree, D. C.

AU - Gaus, A.

AU - Hirst, P. M.

AU - Mullins, C. A.

AU - Schupp, James Rawlinson

PY - 2001/7/1

Y1 - 2001/7/1

N2 - At 12 sites in the United States, trials were established in 1990 which included four apple (Malus X domestica Borkh.) cultivars ('Smoothee Golden Delicious', 'Nicobel Jonagold', 'Empire', and 'Law Rome Beauty') in all combinations on five rootstocks (M.9 EMLA, B.9, Mark, O.3, and M.26 EMLA). After ten growing seasons, rootstock and scion cultivar interacted significantly to affect trunk cross-sectional area (TCA), root suckering, yield efficiency, and fruit size but not survival or yield per tree. In all cases these statistically significant interactions contributed minimally to the variability among rootstocks and were relatively unimportant in determining tree performance. Comparing cultivars after 10 years, survival was greatest for 'Empire' and poorest for 'Rome'. 'Jonagold' had the largest TCA, and 'Empire' and 'Rome' had the smallest. Root suckering occurred most prevalently with 'Empire'. 'Rome' yielded the most, and 'Jonagold' and 'Empire' yielded the least. 'Rome' trees also were the most yield efficient, and 'Jonagold' trees were the least efficient. Largest fruit were 'Rome' and 'Jonagold'. Comparing rootstock effects over 10 years, B.9 resulted in the greater tree survival than did O.3. M.9 EMLA, and Mark, and M.26 EMLA resulted in intermediate survival. Trees with the greatest TCA were on M.26 EMLA. Trees on M.9 EMLA and those on O.3 were similar and significantly smaller. Trees on B.9 and those on Mark were similar in size and the smallest in the trial. The greatest root suckering developed from B.9, Mark, and O.3, and the least came from M.26 EMLA. Trees on M.26 EMLA, O.3, and M.9 EMLA yielded similarly and significantly more than those on B.9 or Mark. The most yield efficient trees, however, were on B.9 and Mark, and the least were on M.26 EMLA. M.26 EMLA and M.9 EMLA resulted in the largest fruit size, and Mark resulted in the smallest.

AB - At 12 sites in the United States, trials were established in 1990 which included four apple (Malus X domestica Borkh.) cultivars ('Smoothee Golden Delicious', 'Nicobel Jonagold', 'Empire', and 'Law Rome Beauty') in all combinations on five rootstocks (M.9 EMLA, B.9, Mark, O.3, and M.26 EMLA). After ten growing seasons, rootstock and scion cultivar interacted significantly to affect trunk cross-sectional area (TCA), root suckering, yield efficiency, and fruit size but not survival or yield per tree. In all cases these statistically significant interactions contributed minimally to the variability among rootstocks and were relatively unimportant in determining tree performance. Comparing cultivars after 10 years, survival was greatest for 'Empire' and poorest for 'Rome'. 'Jonagold' had the largest TCA, and 'Empire' and 'Rome' had the smallest. Root suckering occurred most prevalently with 'Empire'. 'Rome' yielded the most, and 'Jonagold' and 'Empire' yielded the least. 'Rome' trees also were the most yield efficient, and 'Jonagold' trees were the least efficient. Largest fruit were 'Rome' and 'Jonagold'. Comparing rootstock effects over 10 years, B.9 resulted in the greater tree survival than did O.3. M.9 EMLA, and Mark, and M.26 EMLA resulted in intermediate survival. Trees with the greatest TCA were on M.26 EMLA. Trees on M.9 EMLA and those on O.3 were similar and significantly smaller. Trees on B.9 and those on Mark were similar in size and the smallest in the trial. The greatest root suckering developed from B.9, Mark, and O.3, and the least came from M.26 EMLA. Trees on M.26 EMLA, O.3, and M.9 EMLA yielded similarly and significantly more than those on B.9 or Mark. The most yield efficient trees, however, were on B.9 and Mark, and the least were on M.26 EMLA. M.26 EMLA and M.9 EMLA resulted in the largest fruit size, and Mark resulted in the smallest.

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=0008732133&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=0008732133&partnerID=8YFLogxK

M3 - Article

VL - 55

SP - 131

EP - 137

JO - Journal of the American Pomological Society

JF - Journal of the American Pomological Society

SN - 1527-3741

IS - 3

ER -