Quantifying Variability in Assessing the Risk of Early-Age Cracking in Restrained Concrete Elements

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingChapter

Abstract

Civil Engineers frequently perform calculations based on material properties that represent either the 'worst case' or the 'average' properties. While these approaches are extremely helpful in simplifying computations, they can fail to quantify how variability from different sources combines to influence the overall performance of the system. This paper describes two approaches to quantify the variation in residual stress development and the risk of cracking in concrete. First, the paper illustrates the use of a Monte Carlo simulation procedure to quantify the residual stresses and age of cracking for a restrained concrete element due to variability in material properties, environmental conditions, and construction procedures. Second, the paper illustrates how statistical analysis can be directly applied to the problem using an approach that is similar to that used in the design of steel structures (a Load and Resistance Factor Design approach).This paper begins with a short review of a model that computes residual stress development in a restrained concrete element. The paper then describes a Monte Carlo modeling approach that was added to the model to account for variability in materials, construction practices, and environmental conditions. The results show that even low variability in material inputs results in substantial scatter in the predicted time of cracking.An alternative approach to predict the time of cracking is then presented that is similar to the one used for the design of steel structures (Load and Resistance Factor Design - LRFD). The LRFD approach enables the computation of a reliability index β which can quantify a material's potential for cracking. The results indicate that, as one may expect, as the magnitude of shrinkage coefficient increases, the potential for failure increases. Results also show that when the free shrinkage is reduced to a sufficient level, cracking will no longer be observed. The LRFD method enables the level of shrinkage to be quantified and this can then be used in the development of mixture proportioning procedures for mixtures containing shrinkage reducing admixtures (SRA).

Original languageEnglish (US)
Title of host publicationBrittle Matrix Composites 8
PublisherElsevier Ltd
Pages331-342
Number of pages12
ISBN (Print)9781845690311
DOIs
StatePublished - Dec 1 2007

Fingerprint

Concretes
Residual stresses
Steel structures
Materials properties
Statistical methods
Engineers
Monte Carlo simulation

All Science Journal Classification (ASJC) codes

  • Engineering(all)

Cite this

Radlinska, Aleksandra ; Weiss, Jason. / Quantifying Variability in Assessing the Risk of Early-Age Cracking in Restrained Concrete Elements. Brittle Matrix Composites 8. Elsevier Ltd, 2007. pp. 331-342
@inbook{b1aef2e4762e42eabb5756204ef29736,
title = "Quantifying Variability in Assessing the Risk of Early-Age Cracking in Restrained Concrete Elements",
abstract = "Civil Engineers frequently perform calculations based on material properties that represent either the 'worst case' or the 'average' properties. While these approaches are extremely helpful in simplifying computations, they can fail to quantify how variability from different sources combines to influence the overall performance of the system. This paper describes two approaches to quantify the variation in residual stress development and the risk of cracking in concrete. First, the paper illustrates the use of a Monte Carlo simulation procedure to quantify the residual stresses and age of cracking for a restrained concrete element due to variability in material properties, environmental conditions, and construction procedures. Second, the paper illustrates how statistical analysis can be directly applied to the problem using an approach that is similar to that used in the design of steel structures (a Load and Resistance Factor Design approach).This paper begins with a short review of a model that computes residual stress development in a restrained concrete element. The paper then describes a Monte Carlo modeling approach that was added to the model to account for variability in materials, construction practices, and environmental conditions. The results show that even low variability in material inputs results in substantial scatter in the predicted time of cracking.An alternative approach to predict the time of cracking is then presented that is similar to the one used for the design of steel structures (Load and Resistance Factor Design - LRFD). The LRFD approach enables the computation of a reliability index β which can quantify a material's potential for cracking. The results indicate that, as one may expect, as the magnitude of shrinkage coefficient increases, the potential for failure increases. Results also show that when the free shrinkage is reduced to a sufficient level, cracking will no longer be observed. The LRFD method enables the level of shrinkage to be quantified and this can then be used in the development of mixture proportioning procedures for mixtures containing shrinkage reducing admixtures (SRA).",
author = "Aleksandra Radlinska and Jason Weiss",
year = "2007",
month = "12",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1533/9780857093080.331",
language = "English (US)",
isbn = "9781845690311",
pages = "331--342",
booktitle = "Brittle Matrix Composites 8",
publisher = "Elsevier Ltd",
address = "United Kingdom",

}

Quantifying Variability in Assessing the Risk of Early-Age Cracking in Restrained Concrete Elements. / Radlinska, Aleksandra; Weiss, Jason.

Brittle Matrix Composites 8. Elsevier Ltd, 2007. p. 331-342.

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingChapter

TY - CHAP

T1 - Quantifying Variability in Assessing the Risk of Early-Age Cracking in Restrained Concrete Elements

AU - Radlinska, Aleksandra

AU - Weiss, Jason

PY - 2007/12/1

Y1 - 2007/12/1

N2 - Civil Engineers frequently perform calculations based on material properties that represent either the 'worst case' or the 'average' properties. While these approaches are extremely helpful in simplifying computations, they can fail to quantify how variability from different sources combines to influence the overall performance of the system. This paper describes two approaches to quantify the variation in residual stress development and the risk of cracking in concrete. First, the paper illustrates the use of a Monte Carlo simulation procedure to quantify the residual stresses and age of cracking for a restrained concrete element due to variability in material properties, environmental conditions, and construction procedures. Second, the paper illustrates how statistical analysis can be directly applied to the problem using an approach that is similar to that used in the design of steel structures (a Load and Resistance Factor Design approach).This paper begins with a short review of a model that computes residual stress development in a restrained concrete element. The paper then describes a Monte Carlo modeling approach that was added to the model to account for variability in materials, construction practices, and environmental conditions. The results show that even low variability in material inputs results in substantial scatter in the predicted time of cracking.An alternative approach to predict the time of cracking is then presented that is similar to the one used for the design of steel structures (Load and Resistance Factor Design - LRFD). The LRFD approach enables the computation of a reliability index β which can quantify a material's potential for cracking. The results indicate that, as one may expect, as the magnitude of shrinkage coefficient increases, the potential for failure increases. Results also show that when the free shrinkage is reduced to a sufficient level, cracking will no longer be observed. The LRFD method enables the level of shrinkage to be quantified and this can then be used in the development of mixture proportioning procedures for mixtures containing shrinkage reducing admixtures (SRA).

AB - Civil Engineers frequently perform calculations based on material properties that represent either the 'worst case' or the 'average' properties. While these approaches are extremely helpful in simplifying computations, they can fail to quantify how variability from different sources combines to influence the overall performance of the system. This paper describes two approaches to quantify the variation in residual stress development and the risk of cracking in concrete. First, the paper illustrates the use of a Monte Carlo simulation procedure to quantify the residual stresses and age of cracking for a restrained concrete element due to variability in material properties, environmental conditions, and construction procedures. Second, the paper illustrates how statistical analysis can be directly applied to the problem using an approach that is similar to that used in the design of steel structures (a Load and Resistance Factor Design approach).This paper begins with a short review of a model that computes residual stress development in a restrained concrete element. The paper then describes a Monte Carlo modeling approach that was added to the model to account for variability in materials, construction practices, and environmental conditions. The results show that even low variability in material inputs results in substantial scatter in the predicted time of cracking.An alternative approach to predict the time of cracking is then presented that is similar to the one used for the design of steel structures (Load and Resistance Factor Design - LRFD). The LRFD approach enables the computation of a reliability index β which can quantify a material's potential for cracking. The results indicate that, as one may expect, as the magnitude of shrinkage coefficient increases, the potential for failure increases. Results also show that when the free shrinkage is reduced to a sufficient level, cracking will no longer be observed. The LRFD method enables the level of shrinkage to be quantified and this can then be used in the development of mixture proportioning procedures for mixtures containing shrinkage reducing admixtures (SRA).

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84903909406&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=84903909406&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1533/9780857093080.331

DO - 10.1533/9780857093080.331

M3 - Chapter

AN - SCOPUS:84903909406

SN - 9781845690311

SP - 331

EP - 342

BT - Brittle Matrix Composites 8

PB - Elsevier Ltd

ER -