Stabilizing the Benjamin-Feir instability

Harvey Segur, Diane Marie Henderson, John Carter, Joe Hammack, Cong Ming Li, Dana Pheiff, Katherine Socha

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

108 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

The Benjamin-Feir instability is a modulational instability in which a uniform train of oscillatory waves of moderate amplitude loses energy to a small perturbation of other waves with nearly the same frequency and direction. The concept is well established in water waves, in plasmas and in optics. In each of these applications, the nonlinear Schrödinger equation is also well established as an approximate model based on the same assumptions as required for the derivation of the Benjamin-Feir theory: a narrow-banded spectrum of waves of moderate amplitude, propagating primarily in one direction in a dispersive medium with little or no dissipation. In this paper, we show that for waves with narrow bandwidth and moderate amplitude, any amount of dissipation (of a certain type) stabilizes the instability. We arrive at this stability result first by proving it rigorously for a damped version of the nonlinear Schr̈dinger equation, and then by confirming our theoretical predictions with laboratory experiments on waves of moderate amplitude in deep water. The Benjamin-Feir instability is often cited as the first step in a nonlinear process that spreads energy from an initially narrow bandwidth to a broader bandwidth. In this process, sidebands grow exponentially until nonlinear interactions eventually bound their growth. In the presence of damping, this process might still occur, but our work identifies another possibility: damping can stop the growth of perturbations before nonlinear interactions become important. In this case, if the perturbations are small enough initially, then they never grow large enough for nonlinear interactions to become important.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)229-271
Number of pages43
JournalJournal of Fluid Mechanics
Volume539
DOIs
StatePublished - Sep 25 2005

Fingerprint

bandwidth
Bandwidth
Nonlinear equations
perturbation
nonlinear equations
dissipation
Damping
damping
water waves
deep water
Water waves
interactions
sidebands
Optics
derivation
optics
Plasmas
energy
predictions
Water

All Science Journal Classification (ASJC) codes

  • Condensed Matter Physics
  • Mechanics of Materials
  • Mechanical Engineering

Cite this

Segur, H., Henderson, D. M., Carter, J., Hammack, J., Li, C. M., Pheiff, D., & Socha, K. (2005). Stabilizing the Benjamin-Feir instability. Journal of Fluid Mechanics, 539, 229-271. https://doi.org/10.1017/S002211200500563X
Segur, Harvey ; Henderson, Diane Marie ; Carter, John ; Hammack, Joe ; Li, Cong Ming ; Pheiff, Dana ; Socha, Katherine. / Stabilizing the Benjamin-Feir instability. In: Journal of Fluid Mechanics. 2005 ; Vol. 539. pp. 229-271.
@article{909375f6413e49ab96334a7ed4c81a93,
title = "Stabilizing the Benjamin-Feir instability",
abstract = "The Benjamin-Feir instability is a modulational instability in which a uniform train of oscillatory waves of moderate amplitude loses energy to a small perturbation of other waves with nearly the same frequency and direction. The concept is well established in water waves, in plasmas and in optics. In each of these applications, the nonlinear Schr{\"o}dinger equation is also well established as an approximate model based on the same assumptions as required for the derivation of the Benjamin-Feir theory: a narrow-banded spectrum of waves of moderate amplitude, propagating primarily in one direction in a dispersive medium with little or no dissipation. In this paper, we show that for waves with narrow bandwidth and moderate amplitude, any amount of dissipation (of a certain type) stabilizes the instability. We arrive at this stability result first by proving it rigorously for a damped version of the nonlinear Schr̈dinger equation, and then by confirming our theoretical predictions with laboratory experiments on waves of moderate amplitude in deep water. The Benjamin-Feir instability is often cited as the first step in a nonlinear process that spreads energy from an initially narrow bandwidth to a broader bandwidth. In this process, sidebands grow exponentially until nonlinear interactions eventually bound their growth. In the presence of damping, this process might still occur, but our work identifies another possibility: damping can stop the growth of perturbations before nonlinear interactions become important. In this case, if the perturbations are small enough initially, then they never grow large enough for nonlinear interactions to become important.",
author = "Harvey Segur and Henderson, {Diane Marie} and John Carter and Joe Hammack and Li, {Cong Ming} and Dana Pheiff and Katherine Socha",
year = "2005",
month = "9",
day = "25",
doi = "10.1017/S002211200500563X",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "539",
pages = "229--271",
journal = "Journal of Fluid Mechanics",
issn = "0022-1120",
publisher = "Cambridge University Press",

}

Segur, H, Henderson, DM, Carter, J, Hammack, J, Li, CM, Pheiff, D & Socha, K 2005, 'Stabilizing the Benjamin-Feir instability', Journal of Fluid Mechanics, vol. 539, pp. 229-271. https://doi.org/10.1017/S002211200500563X

Stabilizing the Benjamin-Feir instability. / Segur, Harvey; Henderson, Diane Marie; Carter, John; Hammack, Joe; Li, Cong Ming; Pheiff, Dana; Socha, Katherine.

In: Journal of Fluid Mechanics, Vol. 539, 25.09.2005, p. 229-271.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - Stabilizing the Benjamin-Feir instability

AU - Segur, Harvey

AU - Henderson, Diane Marie

AU - Carter, John

AU - Hammack, Joe

AU - Li, Cong Ming

AU - Pheiff, Dana

AU - Socha, Katherine

PY - 2005/9/25

Y1 - 2005/9/25

N2 - The Benjamin-Feir instability is a modulational instability in which a uniform train of oscillatory waves of moderate amplitude loses energy to a small perturbation of other waves with nearly the same frequency and direction. The concept is well established in water waves, in plasmas and in optics. In each of these applications, the nonlinear Schrödinger equation is also well established as an approximate model based on the same assumptions as required for the derivation of the Benjamin-Feir theory: a narrow-banded spectrum of waves of moderate amplitude, propagating primarily in one direction in a dispersive medium with little or no dissipation. In this paper, we show that for waves with narrow bandwidth and moderate amplitude, any amount of dissipation (of a certain type) stabilizes the instability. We arrive at this stability result first by proving it rigorously for a damped version of the nonlinear Schr̈dinger equation, and then by confirming our theoretical predictions with laboratory experiments on waves of moderate amplitude in deep water. The Benjamin-Feir instability is often cited as the first step in a nonlinear process that spreads energy from an initially narrow bandwidth to a broader bandwidth. In this process, sidebands grow exponentially until nonlinear interactions eventually bound their growth. In the presence of damping, this process might still occur, but our work identifies another possibility: damping can stop the growth of perturbations before nonlinear interactions become important. In this case, if the perturbations are small enough initially, then they never grow large enough for nonlinear interactions to become important.

AB - The Benjamin-Feir instability is a modulational instability in which a uniform train of oscillatory waves of moderate amplitude loses energy to a small perturbation of other waves with nearly the same frequency and direction. The concept is well established in water waves, in plasmas and in optics. In each of these applications, the nonlinear Schrödinger equation is also well established as an approximate model based on the same assumptions as required for the derivation of the Benjamin-Feir theory: a narrow-banded spectrum of waves of moderate amplitude, propagating primarily in one direction in a dispersive medium with little or no dissipation. In this paper, we show that for waves with narrow bandwidth and moderate amplitude, any amount of dissipation (of a certain type) stabilizes the instability. We arrive at this stability result first by proving it rigorously for a damped version of the nonlinear Schr̈dinger equation, and then by confirming our theoretical predictions with laboratory experiments on waves of moderate amplitude in deep water. The Benjamin-Feir instability is often cited as the first step in a nonlinear process that spreads energy from an initially narrow bandwidth to a broader bandwidth. In this process, sidebands grow exponentially until nonlinear interactions eventually bound their growth. In the presence of damping, this process might still occur, but our work identifies another possibility: damping can stop the growth of perturbations before nonlinear interactions become important. In this case, if the perturbations are small enough initially, then they never grow large enough for nonlinear interactions to become important.

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=21344464558&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=21344464558&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1017/S002211200500563X

DO - 10.1017/S002211200500563X

M3 - Article

VL - 539

SP - 229

EP - 271

JO - Journal of Fluid Mechanics

JF - Journal of Fluid Mechanics

SN - 0022-1120

ER -

Segur H, Henderson DM, Carter J, Hammack J, Li CM, Pheiff D et al. Stabilizing the Benjamin-Feir instability. Journal of Fluid Mechanics. 2005 Sep 25;539:229-271. https://doi.org/10.1017/S002211200500563X