Testing the equality of two proportions for combined unilateral and bilateral data

Yanbo Pei, Man Lai Tang, Jianhua Guo

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

7 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

In many medical comparative studies (e.g., comparison of two treatments in an otolaryngological study), subjects may produce either bilateral (e.g., responses from a pair of ears) or unilateral (response from only one ear) data. For bilateral cases, it is meaningful to assume that the information between the two ears from the same subject are generally highly correlated. In this article, we would like to test the equality of the successful cure rates between two treatments with the presence of combined unilateral and bilateral data. Based on the dependence and independence models, we study ten test statistics which utilize both the unilateral and bilateral data. The performance of these statistics will be evaluated with respect to their empirical Type I error rates and powers under different configurations. We find that both Rosner's and Wald-type statistics based on the dependence model and constrained maximum likelihood estimates (under the null hypothesis) perform satisfactorily for small to large samples and are hence recommended. We illustrate our methodologies with a real data set from an otolaryngology study.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)1515-1529
Number of pages15
JournalCommunications in Statistics: Simulation and Computation
Volume37
Issue number8
DOIs
StatePublished - Sep 1 2008

Fingerprint

Equality
Proportion
Statistics
Testing
Maximum likelihood
Type I Error Rate
Maximum Likelihood Estimate
Null hypothesis
Comparative Study
Test Statistic
Configuration
Methodology
Model

All Science Journal Classification (ASJC) codes

  • Modeling and Simulation
  • Statistics and Probability

Cite this

@article{6137b28a4cfb4284a30fa4b6661bbdbf,
title = "Testing the equality of two proportions for combined unilateral and bilateral data",
abstract = "In many medical comparative studies (e.g., comparison of two treatments in an otolaryngological study), subjects may produce either bilateral (e.g., responses from a pair of ears) or unilateral (response from only one ear) data. For bilateral cases, it is meaningful to assume that the information between the two ears from the same subject are generally highly correlated. In this article, we would like to test the equality of the successful cure rates between two treatments with the presence of combined unilateral and bilateral data. Based on the dependence and independence models, we study ten test statistics which utilize both the unilateral and bilateral data. The performance of these statistics will be evaluated with respect to their empirical Type I error rates and powers under different configurations. We find that both Rosner's and Wald-type statistics based on the dependence model and constrained maximum likelihood estimates (under the null hypothesis) perform satisfactorily for small to large samples and are hence recommended. We illustrate our methodologies with a real data set from an otolaryngology study.",
author = "Yanbo Pei and Tang, {Man Lai} and Jianhua Guo",
year = "2008",
month = "9",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1080/03610910802140232",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "37",
pages = "1515--1529",
journal = "Communications in Statistics Part B: Simulation and Computation",
issn = "0361-0918",
publisher = "Taylor and Francis Ltd.",
number = "8",

}

Testing the equality of two proportions for combined unilateral and bilateral data. / Pei, Yanbo; Tang, Man Lai; Guo, Jianhua.

In: Communications in Statistics: Simulation and Computation, Vol. 37, No. 8, 01.09.2008, p. 1515-1529.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - Testing the equality of two proportions for combined unilateral and bilateral data

AU - Pei, Yanbo

AU - Tang, Man Lai

AU - Guo, Jianhua

PY - 2008/9/1

Y1 - 2008/9/1

N2 - In many medical comparative studies (e.g., comparison of two treatments in an otolaryngological study), subjects may produce either bilateral (e.g., responses from a pair of ears) or unilateral (response from only one ear) data. For bilateral cases, it is meaningful to assume that the information between the two ears from the same subject are generally highly correlated. In this article, we would like to test the equality of the successful cure rates between two treatments with the presence of combined unilateral and bilateral data. Based on the dependence and independence models, we study ten test statistics which utilize both the unilateral and bilateral data. The performance of these statistics will be evaluated with respect to their empirical Type I error rates and powers under different configurations. We find that both Rosner's and Wald-type statistics based on the dependence model and constrained maximum likelihood estimates (under the null hypothesis) perform satisfactorily for small to large samples and are hence recommended. We illustrate our methodologies with a real data set from an otolaryngology study.

AB - In many medical comparative studies (e.g., comparison of two treatments in an otolaryngological study), subjects may produce either bilateral (e.g., responses from a pair of ears) or unilateral (response from only one ear) data. For bilateral cases, it is meaningful to assume that the information between the two ears from the same subject are generally highly correlated. In this article, we would like to test the equality of the successful cure rates between two treatments with the presence of combined unilateral and bilateral data. Based on the dependence and independence models, we study ten test statistics which utilize both the unilateral and bilateral data. The performance of these statistics will be evaluated with respect to their empirical Type I error rates and powers under different configurations. We find that both Rosner's and Wald-type statistics based on the dependence model and constrained maximum likelihood estimates (under the null hypothesis) perform satisfactorily for small to large samples and are hence recommended. We illustrate our methodologies with a real data set from an otolaryngology study.

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=52649173761&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=52649173761&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1080/03610910802140232

DO - 10.1080/03610910802140232

M3 - Article

VL - 37

SP - 1515

EP - 1529

JO - Communications in Statistics Part B: Simulation and Computation

JF - Communications in Statistics Part B: Simulation and Computation

SN - 0361-0918

IS - 8

ER -