The importance of intra-management practice variability in sediment and phosphorus loss from agricultural fields

Melissa D. Miller, Lou S. Saporito, Anthony R. Buda, Heather E. Gall, Tamie L. Veith, Charles M. White, Clinton F. Williams, Kathryn J. Brasier, Peter J.A. Kleinman, John E. Watson

Research output: Contribution to conferencePaper

Abstract

Eutrophication and sedimentation are pervasive challenges in the Chesapeake Bay watershed. Shallow-disk manure injection is a promising technology to mitigate phosphorus (P) losses in runoff while maintaining the water quality benefits of no-till, including reducing particulate P and sediment losses. However, its effectiveness as a P mitigation strategy is not fully understood, as hydrologic variability exists across spatial and temporal scales, confounding the results of field studies seeking to quantify the benefits of shallow-disk injection. In this study, we regressed loads of total solids (TS), total P (TP), dissolved P (DP), and particulate P (PP) against flow depths to evaluate the effectiveness of shallow-disk manure injection versus broadcasting for reducing P and sediment losses. Overland and subsurface flow from twelve plots in central Pennsylvania were measured and sampled for TS and P from January 2013 to May 2017. The plots received manure via either surface broadcasting or shallow-disk injection for three years, followed by two years of broadcasting across all plots. Load-discharge (L-Q) relationships were developed to determine how P and TS losses changed with increasing flow. L-Q analyses revealed dilution of all P constituents and near-chemostatic behavior for TS for both application methods. However, shallow-disk injection was more effective in promoting dilution of DP, and to a lesser extent, TP, with no difference between application methods for TS and PP. Intra-practice variability was largely dependent on relative contributions from overland and subsurface flow, due to increased dilution from subsurface flow. Overall, the results suggest that shallow-disk injection appears to be an effective practice to reduce TP and DP losses without negating the benefits of no-till.

Original languageEnglish (US)
DOIs
StatePublished - Jan 1 2018
EventASABE 2018 Annual International Meeting - Detroit, United States
Duration: Jul 29 2018Aug 1 2018

Other

OtherASABE 2018 Annual International Meeting
CountryUnited States
CityDetroit
Period7/29/188/1/18

Fingerprint

Phosphorus
total solids
Sediments
Manures
injection
phosphorus
sediments
Broadcasting
subsurface flow
Dilution
particulates
overland flow
application methods
no-tillage
Eutrophication
Watersheds
Runoff
Sedimentation
pollution control
Chesapeake Bay

All Science Journal Classification (ASJC) codes

  • Bioengineering
  • Agronomy and Crop Science

Cite this

Miller, M. D., Saporito, L. S., Buda, A. R., Gall, H. E., Veith, T. L., White, C. M., ... Watson, J. E. (2018). The importance of intra-management practice variability in sediment and phosphorus loss from agricultural fields. Paper presented at ASABE 2018 Annual International Meeting, Detroit, United States. https://doi.org/10.13031/aim.201801434
Miller, Melissa D. ; Saporito, Lou S. ; Buda, Anthony R. ; Gall, Heather E. ; Veith, Tamie L. ; White, Charles M. ; Williams, Clinton F. ; Brasier, Kathryn J. ; Kleinman, Peter J.A. ; Watson, John E. / The importance of intra-management practice variability in sediment and phosphorus loss from agricultural fields. Paper presented at ASABE 2018 Annual International Meeting, Detroit, United States.
@conference{11948ffd0d2f4e90a1b4b9b8bce9d59c,
title = "The importance of intra-management practice variability in sediment and phosphorus loss from agricultural fields",
abstract = "Eutrophication and sedimentation are pervasive challenges in the Chesapeake Bay watershed. Shallow-disk manure injection is a promising technology to mitigate phosphorus (P) losses in runoff while maintaining the water quality benefits of no-till, including reducing particulate P and sediment losses. However, its effectiveness as a P mitigation strategy is not fully understood, as hydrologic variability exists across spatial and temporal scales, confounding the results of field studies seeking to quantify the benefits of shallow-disk injection. In this study, we regressed loads of total solids (TS), total P (TP), dissolved P (DP), and particulate P (PP) against flow depths to evaluate the effectiveness of shallow-disk manure injection versus broadcasting for reducing P and sediment losses. Overland and subsurface flow from twelve plots in central Pennsylvania were measured and sampled for TS and P from January 2013 to May 2017. The plots received manure via either surface broadcasting or shallow-disk injection for three years, followed by two years of broadcasting across all plots. Load-discharge (L-Q) relationships were developed to determine how P and TS losses changed with increasing flow. L-Q analyses revealed dilution of all P constituents and near-chemostatic behavior for TS for both application methods. However, shallow-disk injection was more effective in promoting dilution of DP, and to a lesser extent, TP, with no difference between application methods for TS and PP. Intra-practice variability was largely dependent on relative contributions from overland and subsurface flow, due to increased dilution from subsurface flow. Overall, the results suggest that shallow-disk injection appears to be an effective practice to reduce TP and DP losses without negating the benefits of no-till.",
author = "Miller, {Melissa D.} and Saporito, {Lou S.} and Buda, {Anthony R.} and Gall, {Heather E.} and Veith, {Tamie L.} and White, {Charles M.} and Williams, {Clinton F.} and Brasier, {Kathryn J.} and Kleinman, {Peter J.A.} and Watson, {John E.}",
year = "2018",
month = "1",
day = "1",
doi = "10.13031/aim.201801434",
language = "English (US)",
note = "ASABE 2018 Annual International Meeting ; Conference date: 29-07-2018 Through 01-08-2018",

}

Miller, MD, Saporito, LS, Buda, AR, Gall, HE, Veith, TL, White, CM, Williams, CF, Brasier, KJ, Kleinman, PJA & Watson, JE 2018, 'The importance of intra-management practice variability in sediment and phosphorus loss from agricultural fields', Paper presented at ASABE 2018 Annual International Meeting, Detroit, United States, 7/29/18 - 8/1/18. https://doi.org/10.13031/aim.201801434

The importance of intra-management practice variability in sediment and phosphorus loss from agricultural fields. / Miller, Melissa D.; Saporito, Lou S.; Buda, Anthony R.; Gall, Heather E.; Veith, Tamie L.; White, Charles M.; Williams, Clinton F.; Brasier, Kathryn J.; Kleinman, Peter J.A.; Watson, John E.

2018. Paper presented at ASABE 2018 Annual International Meeting, Detroit, United States.

Research output: Contribution to conferencePaper

TY - CONF

T1 - The importance of intra-management practice variability in sediment and phosphorus loss from agricultural fields

AU - Miller, Melissa D.

AU - Saporito, Lou S.

AU - Buda, Anthony R.

AU - Gall, Heather E.

AU - Veith, Tamie L.

AU - White, Charles M.

AU - Williams, Clinton F.

AU - Brasier, Kathryn J.

AU - Kleinman, Peter J.A.

AU - Watson, John E.

PY - 2018/1/1

Y1 - 2018/1/1

N2 - Eutrophication and sedimentation are pervasive challenges in the Chesapeake Bay watershed. Shallow-disk manure injection is a promising technology to mitigate phosphorus (P) losses in runoff while maintaining the water quality benefits of no-till, including reducing particulate P and sediment losses. However, its effectiveness as a P mitigation strategy is not fully understood, as hydrologic variability exists across spatial and temporal scales, confounding the results of field studies seeking to quantify the benefits of shallow-disk injection. In this study, we regressed loads of total solids (TS), total P (TP), dissolved P (DP), and particulate P (PP) against flow depths to evaluate the effectiveness of shallow-disk manure injection versus broadcasting for reducing P and sediment losses. Overland and subsurface flow from twelve plots in central Pennsylvania were measured and sampled for TS and P from January 2013 to May 2017. The plots received manure via either surface broadcasting or shallow-disk injection for three years, followed by two years of broadcasting across all plots. Load-discharge (L-Q) relationships were developed to determine how P and TS losses changed with increasing flow. L-Q analyses revealed dilution of all P constituents and near-chemostatic behavior for TS for both application methods. However, shallow-disk injection was more effective in promoting dilution of DP, and to a lesser extent, TP, with no difference between application methods for TS and PP. Intra-practice variability was largely dependent on relative contributions from overland and subsurface flow, due to increased dilution from subsurface flow. Overall, the results suggest that shallow-disk injection appears to be an effective practice to reduce TP and DP losses without negating the benefits of no-till.

AB - Eutrophication and sedimentation are pervasive challenges in the Chesapeake Bay watershed. Shallow-disk manure injection is a promising technology to mitigate phosphorus (P) losses in runoff while maintaining the water quality benefits of no-till, including reducing particulate P and sediment losses. However, its effectiveness as a P mitigation strategy is not fully understood, as hydrologic variability exists across spatial and temporal scales, confounding the results of field studies seeking to quantify the benefits of shallow-disk injection. In this study, we regressed loads of total solids (TS), total P (TP), dissolved P (DP), and particulate P (PP) against flow depths to evaluate the effectiveness of shallow-disk manure injection versus broadcasting for reducing P and sediment losses. Overland and subsurface flow from twelve plots in central Pennsylvania were measured and sampled for TS and P from January 2013 to May 2017. The plots received manure via either surface broadcasting or shallow-disk injection for three years, followed by two years of broadcasting across all plots. Load-discharge (L-Q) relationships were developed to determine how P and TS losses changed with increasing flow. L-Q analyses revealed dilution of all P constituents and near-chemostatic behavior for TS for both application methods. However, shallow-disk injection was more effective in promoting dilution of DP, and to a lesser extent, TP, with no difference between application methods for TS and PP. Intra-practice variability was largely dependent on relative contributions from overland and subsurface flow, due to increased dilution from subsurface flow. Overall, the results suggest that shallow-disk injection appears to be an effective practice to reduce TP and DP losses without negating the benefits of no-till.

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85054175432&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=85054175432&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.13031/aim.201801434

DO - 10.13031/aim.201801434

M3 - Paper

AN - SCOPUS:85054175432

ER -

Miller MD, Saporito LS, Buda AR, Gall HE, Veith TL, White CM et al. The importance of intra-management practice variability in sediment and phosphorus loss from agricultural fields. 2018. Paper presented at ASABE 2018 Annual International Meeting, Detroit, United States. https://doi.org/10.13031/aim.201801434