The Red Bird River Shelter (15CY52) Revisited: The Archaeology of the Cherokee Syllabary and of Sequoyah in Kentucky

Jan F. Simek, Beau Duke Carroll, Julie Reed, Alan Cressler, Tom Belt, Wayna Adams, Mary White

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

This article reanalyzes petroglyphs from the Red Bird River Shelter (15CY52), a small sandstone shelter in Kentucky. In 2009-2013, it was claimed that some of the carvings at the site represented the earliest known examples of Cherokee Syllabary writing, dating to the first two decades of the nineteenth century. It was also suggested that Sequoyah, the Cherokee artist and intellectual who invented the Cherokee Syllabary in the early nineteenth century, had made these petroglyph versions during a visit to see his white paternal family living in Kentucky. Our reanalysis categorically contests this interpretation. We do not see Cherokee Syllabary writing at Red Bird River Shelter. We do not believe that historical evidence supports the notion that Sequoyah had white relatives in Kentucky whom he visited there at the time required for him to have authored those petroglyphs. We also believe that this account misrepresents Sequoyah's Cherokee identity by tying him to white relatives for whom there is no historical warrant. We argue that the Red Bird River Shelter is a significant precontact petroglyph site with several panels of line-and-groove petroglyphs overlain by numerous examples of modern graffiti, but there is no Sequoyan Syllabary inscription there.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)302-316
Number of pages15
JournalAmerican Antiquity
Volume84
Issue number2
DOIs
StatePublished - Apr 1 2019

Fingerprint

archaeology
river
nineteenth century
graffiti
artist
interpretation
evidence
Shelter
Petroglyphs
Archaeology
Syllabary
Kentucky
Cherokee
time

All Science Journal Classification (ASJC) codes

  • History
  • Arts and Humanities (miscellaneous)
  • Archaeology
  • Museology

Cite this

Simek, Jan F. ; Carroll, Beau Duke ; Reed, Julie ; Cressler, Alan ; Belt, Tom ; Adams, Wayna ; White, Mary. / The Red Bird River Shelter (15CY52) Revisited : The Archaeology of the Cherokee Syllabary and of Sequoyah in Kentucky. In: American Antiquity. 2019 ; Vol. 84, No. 2. pp. 302-316.
@article{48f0c4b44b064b37b6b1f8a0743b5b33,
title = "The Red Bird River Shelter (15CY52) Revisited: The Archaeology of the Cherokee Syllabary and of Sequoyah in Kentucky",
abstract = "This article reanalyzes petroglyphs from the Red Bird River Shelter (15CY52), a small sandstone shelter in Kentucky. In 2009-2013, it was claimed that some of the carvings at the site represented the earliest known examples of Cherokee Syllabary writing, dating to the first two decades of the nineteenth century. It was also suggested that Sequoyah, the Cherokee artist and intellectual who invented the Cherokee Syllabary in the early nineteenth century, had made these petroglyph versions during a visit to see his white paternal family living in Kentucky. Our reanalysis categorically contests this interpretation. We do not see Cherokee Syllabary writing at Red Bird River Shelter. We do not believe that historical evidence supports the notion that Sequoyah had white relatives in Kentucky whom he visited there at the time required for him to have authored those petroglyphs. We also believe that this account misrepresents Sequoyah's Cherokee identity by tying him to white relatives for whom there is no historical warrant. We argue that the Red Bird River Shelter is a significant precontact petroglyph site with several panels of line-and-groove petroglyphs overlain by numerous examples of modern graffiti, but there is no Sequoyan Syllabary inscription there.",
author = "Simek, {Jan F.} and Carroll, {Beau Duke} and Julie Reed and Alan Cressler and Tom Belt and Wayna Adams and Mary White",
year = "2019",
month = "4",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1017/aaq.2018.89",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "84",
pages = "302--316",
journal = "American Antiquity",
issn = "0002-7316",
publisher = "Society for American Archaeology",
number = "2",

}

The Red Bird River Shelter (15CY52) Revisited : The Archaeology of the Cherokee Syllabary and of Sequoyah in Kentucky. / Simek, Jan F.; Carroll, Beau Duke; Reed, Julie; Cressler, Alan; Belt, Tom; Adams, Wayna; White, Mary.

In: American Antiquity, Vol. 84, No. 2, 01.04.2019, p. 302-316.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - The Red Bird River Shelter (15CY52) Revisited

T2 - The Archaeology of the Cherokee Syllabary and of Sequoyah in Kentucky

AU - Simek, Jan F.

AU - Carroll, Beau Duke

AU - Reed, Julie

AU - Cressler, Alan

AU - Belt, Tom

AU - Adams, Wayna

AU - White, Mary

PY - 2019/4/1

Y1 - 2019/4/1

N2 - This article reanalyzes petroglyphs from the Red Bird River Shelter (15CY52), a small sandstone shelter in Kentucky. In 2009-2013, it was claimed that some of the carvings at the site represented the earliest known examples of Cherokee Syllabary writing, dating to the first two decades of the nineteenth century. It was also suggested that Sequoyah, the Cherokee artist and intellectual who invented the Cherokee Syllabary in the early nineteenth century, had made these petroglyph versions during a visit to see his white paternal family living in Kentucky. Our reanalysis categorically contests this interpretation. We do not see Cherokee Syllabary writing at Red Bird River Shelter. We do not believe that historical evidence supports the notion that Sequoyah had white relatives in Kentucky whom he visited there at the time required for him to have authored those petroglyphs. We also believe that this account misrepresents Sequoyah's Cherokee identity by tying him to white relatives for whom there is no historical warrant. We argue that the Red Bird River Shelter is a significant precontact petroglyph site with several panels of line-and-groove petroglyphs overlain by numerous examples of modern graffiti, but there is no Sequoyan Syllabary inscription there.

AB - This article reanalyzes petroglyphs from the Red Bird River Shelter (15CY52), a small sandstone shelter in Kentucky. In 2009-2013, it was claimed that some of the carvings at the site represented the earliest known examples of Cherokee Syllabary writing, dating to the first two decades of the nineteenth century. It was also suggested that Sequoyah, the Cherokee artist and intellectual who invented the Cherokee Syllabary in the early nineteenth century, had made these petroglyph versions during a visit to see his white paternal family living in Kentucky. Our reanalysis categorically contests this interpretation. We do not see Cherokee Syllabary writing at Red Bird River Shelter. We do not believe that historical evidence supports the notion that Sequoyah had white relatives in Kentucky whom he visited there at the time required for him to have authored those petroglyphs. We also believe that this account misrepresents Sequoyah's Cherokee identity by tying him to white relatives for whom there is no historical warrant. We argue that the Red Bird River Shelter is a significant precontact petroglyph site with several panels of line-and-groove petroglyphs overlain by numerous examples of modern graffiti, but there is no Sequoyan Syllabary inscription there.

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85064994188&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=85064994188&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1017/aaq.2018.89

DO - 10.1017/aaq.2018.89

M3 - Article

AN - SCOPUS:85064994188

VL - 84

SP - 302

EP - 316

JO - American Antiquity

JF - American Antiquity

SN - 0002-7316

IS - 2

ER -