Use of factorial sensitivity analysis in multizone airflow model tuning

Joseph Firrantello, William P. Bahnfleth, Amy Musser, James Freihaut, Jae Weon Jeong

Research output: Contribution to journalConference article

7 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Multizone models provide a relatively simple, rapid means for simulating airflow and contaminant dispersion in complex buildings. However, an untuned model may not agree well with the actual performance of the building it represents. An efficient method for tuning a model, which combines a heuristic approach with factorial sensitivity analysis, is evaluated for the case of a hypothetical single-story building served by three independent air distribution systems. A detailed "virtual" building model is constructed using multizone modeling software and a set of design data and then detuned by changing airflows, flow resistances, and other parameters. A multizone model of the virtual building is constructed using the same design parameters and is tuned by successively correcting its parameters to match values from the virtual building as directed by the sensitivity analysis, which uses the percentage of incorrect interzonal flow directions as the response variable. The method results in improvementfrom 60% incorrect to 10% incorrect after six correction steps. Improvement of the model is confirmed by application of ASTM Standard D 5157-97 for four different simulated tracer release scenarios. Improvement is significantly more rapid using the structured approach than when corrections are made using randomly selected measurements.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)642-651
Number of pages10
JournalASHRAE Transactions
Volume113 PART 1
StatePublished - Aug 23 2007
Event2007 Winter Meeting of the American Society of Heating, Refrigerating and Air-Conditioning Engineers - Dallas, TX, United States
Duration: Jan 27 2007Jan 31 2007

Fingerprint

Sensitivity analysis
Tuning
Impurities
Air

All Science Journal Classification (ASJC) codes

  • Building and Construction
  • Mechanical Engineering

Cite this

Firrantello, Joseph ; Bahnfleth, William P. ; Musser, Amy ; Freihaut, James ; Jeong, Jae Weon. / Use of factorial sensitivity analysis in multizone airflow model tuning. In: ASHRAE Transactions. 2007 ; Vol. 113 PART 1. pp. 642-651.
@article{9f4c05bcd96f45969bc309cb83be23f1,
title = "Use of factorial sensitivity analysis in multizone airflow model tuning",
abstract = "Multizone models provide a relatively simple, rapid means for simulating airflow and contaminant dispersion in complex buildings. However, an untuned model may not agree well with the actual performance of the building it represents. An efficient method for tuning a model, which combines a heuristic approach with factorial sensitivity analysis, is evaluated for the case of a hypothetical single-story building served by three independent air distribution systems. A detailed {"}virtual{"} building model is constructed using multizone modeling software and a set of design data and then detuned by changing airflows, flow resistances, and other parameters. A multizone model of the virtual building is constructed using the same design parameters and is tuned by successively correcting its parameters to match values from the virtual building as directed by the sensitivity analysis, which uses the percentage of incorrect interzonal flow directions as the response variable. The method results in improvementfrom 60{\%} incorrect to 10{\%} incorrect after six correction steps. Improvement of the model is confirmed by application of ASTM Standard D 5157-97 for four different simulated tracer release scenarios. Improvement is significantly more rapid using the structured approach than when corrections are made using randomly selected measurements.",
author = "Joseph Firrantello and Bahnfleth, {William P.} and Amy Musser and James Freihaut and Jeong, {Jae Weon}",
year = "2007",
month = "8",
day = "23",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "113 PART 1",
pages = "642--651",
journal = "ASHRAE Transactions",
issn = "0001-2505",
publisher = "Amer. Soc. Heating, Ref. Air-Conditoning Eng. Inc.",

}

Firrantello, J, Bahnfleth, WP, Musser, A, Freihaut, J & Jeong, JW 2007, 'Use of factorial sensitivity analysis in multizone airflow model tuning', ASHRAE Transactions, vol. 113 PART 1, pp. 642-651.

Use of factorial sensitivity analysis in multizone airflow model tuning. / Firrantello, Joseph; Bahnfleth, William P.; Musser, Amy; Freihaut, James; Jeong, Jae Weon.

In: ASHRAE Transactions, Vol. 113 PART 1, 23.08.2007, p. 642-651.

Research output: Contribution to journalConference article

TY - JOUR

T1 - Use of factorial sensitivity analysis in multizone airflow model tuning

AU - Firrantello, Joseph

AU - Bahnfleth, William P.

AU - Musser, Amy

AU - Freihaut, James

AU - Jeong, Jae Weon

PY - 2007/8/23

Y1 - 2007/8/23

N2 - Multizone models provide a relatively simple, rapid means for simulating airflow and contaminant dispersion in complex buildings. However, an untuned model may not agree well with the actual performance of the building it represents. An efficient method for tuning a model, which combines a heuristic approach with factorial sensitivity analysis, is evaluated for the case of a hypothetical single-story building served by three independent air distribution systems. A detailed "virtual" building model is constructed using multizone modeling software and a set of design data and then detuned by changing airflows, flow resistances, and other parameters. A multizone model of the virtual building is constructed using the same design parameters and is tuned by successively correcting its parameters to match values from the virtual building as directed by the sensitivity analysis, which uses the percentage of incorrect interzonal flow directions as the response variable. The method results in improvementfrom 60% incorrect to 10% incorrect after six correction steps. Improvement of the model is confirmed by application of ASTM Standard D 5157-97 for four different simulated tracer release scenarios. Improvement is significantly more rapid using the structured approach than when corrections are made using randomly selected measurements.

AB - Multizone models provide a relatively simple, rapid means for simulating airflow and contaminant dispersion in complex buildings. However, an untuned model may not agree well with the actual performance of the building it represents. An efficient method for tuning a model, which combines a heuristic approach with factorial sensitivity analysis, is evaluated for the case of a hypothetical single-story building served by three independent air distribution systems. A detailed "virtual" building model is constructed using multizone modeling software and a set of design data and then detuned by changing airflows, flow resistances, and other parameters. A multizone model of the virtual building is constructed using the same design parameters and is tuned by successively correcting its parameters to match values from the virtual building as directed by the sensitivity analysis, which uses the percentage of incorrect interzonal flow directions as the response variable. The method results in improvementfrom 60% incorrect to 10% incorrect after six correction steps. Improvement of the model is confirmed by application of ASTM Standard D 5157-97 for four different simulated tracer release scenarios. Improvement is significantly more rapid using the structured approach than when corrections are made using randomly selected measurements.

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=34547977712&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=34547977712&partnerID=8YFLogxK

M3 - Conference article

AN - SCOPUS:34547977712

VL - 113 PART 1

SP - 642

EP - 651

JO - ASHRAE Transactions

JF - ASHRAE Transactions

SN - 0001-2505

ER -